<p>I took a look at the Brown dept page and found that the 2 year MA in American studies, which is likely more similar to the Columbia program, is awarded as part of the PhD program. You might prefer to apply to the PhD program and see if you get accepted with funding. You will get the MA along the way and likely have a choice to drop the program, or more likely continue with it being paid. No way to find out except to apply and see what offer you get. </p>
<p>I really think the one year program is an entirely different animal and which program is better for you (Brown, Columbia, PhD) depends upon your career goals.</p>