I have no affiliation with either school, both of which are excellent schools that are very different in size and location. And Boston is great. Apples and oranges. We also are not Jesuit or Catholic. I know smart, high-achieving, successful people that have gone to both. Having said all that, I would much rather have my kid look at going to Amherst (or other small LAC) than BC – especially if the cost is similar. I also think being an athlete in the NESCAC would be a great opportunity. Not sure why the “I would not be required to play baseball” is a plus for BC. If you are not liking baseball after Freshman year at Amherst, you can always quit. Many athletes do. But being on a varsity team would seem to be a great way socially to start your college career.