My initial reaction is “hell no” but its probably more complicated than that. Was she tutored before and how was she scoring on practice tests? I say that because I know that Yale asked my daughter to submit ALL of her ACT scores after she submitted her best score (a 34, 11 on the writing). While schools typically claim that submitting all scores can only help a student, I can’t help but wonder how an elite school might view a student who took a test 3-4 times (as opposed to a student just taking it once and “acing” it). If your daughter was confident that she could duplicate or beat her 35 and also do a bit better on the writing portion, I would suggest that she go for it (since it enhances superscore possibilities and a better writing score might help a bit with the elites). Good luck.