Anyone, mind commenting on my why essay??

I’ve already submitted my essay and I know panicking now is useless, but no one had ever read my why essay before I submitted it and some honest response would really soothe my anxiousness a bit right now. I am a US citizen studying in China applying for NYU Tisch RD. My consideration was that Tisch values story-telling ability, so I decided to wrote my essay in the form of a short story, but now that I look at it again, I feel it may be too general and cliche. Please help?? Thx a lot.

Essay:

I rushed out of the subway station, constantly checking with my GPS to ensure that I was in the right direction. Clock ticking, my flight was leaving in a few hours. As I continued with my search anxiously, I thought about why I was so badly in love with her in the first place.

It must be her big heart. Race, gender, sexuality, occupation and nationality all melt away in her tolerant eyes. She cares about who I am as a person, not how I am labeled by society. The people she fosters are so diverse and interesting, only with the same level of commitment to her and to the improvement of the world. I know, instinctively, that I can simply be myself to fit in, because every personality, quirk and idea is celebrated here.

It may also be the coexistence of close-care and independence that solely belongs to her. Indeed, I’ll be granted the maximum of freedom to explore. I see myself analyzing the stage design of Phantom of The Opera at Broadway on a typical internship, holding breathe while gazing at The Starry Sky in MOMA, diving into the opportunities and cultural life in the city of New York. But at the end of the day, every student bonds as a family. My grievance will be embraced with encouragement and a gently push that put me back in the real world of NYC to grow up and improve.

It can also be her progressive and artistic vision. She adapts to the modern time, and offers innovative and up-to-date majors like music marketing and film and television. Film is a unique form of expression that combines all the things that I am passionate about: visual art, photography, music, literature, business and science. Movies sends out message through my unique voice and makes a change in the society. She prepares me for my dream with the one-of-a-kind film program in the US.

But after I turned left at another corner and finally got a sight of her, I realized that, I just love her, I guess. There was no fence that marks her boarder, but even if in the busiest city of the world, I can never miss the bright and vibrant purple color flags that claimed her supremacy and charm. NYU, New York University. I feel free and powerful just by saying these three words.

Also, I wonder if we are allowed to make any updates to Tisch? like new creative ideas/ project etc. ??

for me this essay is very different, but maybe because I am international student and the way how Americans write “why something” essays is different.

the topic was all about of writing an essay, why you chose NYU over any other school and why you are interested in some programs at NYU and no other. you were supposed to tell why you chose to apply to one particular program over another and how NYU would benefit from you, and you from NYU. I feel like your essay is very good and descriptive and vivid, but not really on topic that they asked you to write about. But I hope that i am not right and your essay is just brilliant. Because yeah, for me it looks like a piece of art, but that is an essay saying 'woah ah oh NYU is JUST P E R F E C T" and I guess, they are so done listening how much do you love it, because they wait for you to tell them why YOU are a perfect person to fill NYU like a missing puzzle.

But honestly, this is only my own opinion. Outside of the USA (and from people that I know who also applied), WHY NYU essay is kind of a “motivation letter” that states why they should desire to have you. But excuse me in advance, I may not be right. However, I like your essay so much and I wish you best of luck! :-*

I have a thread on Tisch applications and admissions essays that you can find here: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/new-york-university/1846841-a-letter-of-encouragement-to-tisch-applicants.html

I agree with @classlena that your essay is heavy on praise for the school and light on (completely void of) reasons that you are a great match for the school. However, since applications are past due, there isn’t much you can do about that. Regardless, it’s very well written. I’m sure your portfolio will give you the push you need to get in. Good luck!

@classlena Thank you for your honest comment! And yes, I believe what you said about “why essay” is totally correct, but sadly I realized the mistake in my approach too late : (. Just gonna keep my fingers crossed anyway. Good luck to wherever you are applying to also!

@Rougarou I just finished reading your thread and it was super encouraging!!! You must be a brilliant writer. Thank you for your encouragement : )It means a lot.

Don’t ever post your essays on websites like these. It may get caught in a plagiarism checker and you can get in trouble even though it was yourself that posted it. Ask a moderator to remove it.

^!!! also it seems like you’re more describing why you love new york and then being like btw nyu is cool too at the end. also the painting at the moma is called “the starry night” not the starry sky. also proofread it, there are some grammar/spelling mistakes.

Hi there! I got in ED1 to NYU (although not for Tisch) but I have a pretty good Idea of what a successful “Why NYU” essay should look like (after all, I did get into Stern). Overall, I thought your essay was solid except for one key feature. You seemed to describe why you liked NYC over NYU. When I went to the NYU open house, the admissions counselors stressed that they get hundreds of “Why NYU” essays that talk about NYC instead of NYU specifically. They even said that said that “if you love NYC that much and talk about it in your essay, that doesn’t tell us you want to go to NYU. There are plenty of other colleges in NYC you can go to”. That being said, your essay was still solid and depending on the other parts of your application, you definitely still have a chance of making it in. It’s just that this essay probably wont help you that much.

border not boarder.

It’s quite creative but I think it could be more personal & specific. Don’t worry about it this point. I also live in China btw :slight_smile: you could consider doing an interview with Initial View, it might enhance your application.

I am sorry for assuming that you are an American! I am sorry. My point was just that this essay is usually more like motivation letter, instead of personal statement.

MODERATOR’S NOTE:
The original poster had asked for this thread to be deleted, which we do not do when there are replies. However, in order to allow the thread to sink off the first page, I am closing.