Some schools have very strict rules about kids playing 3 sports, or 2 sports and 1 theatre/show (even longer time commitment). This is why I say it is so important to get an exact grasp of requirements at schools as they vary a lot and how strictly the schools follow their own rules, or give waivers, also varies a LOT!
In MA, because there are so many soccer clubs packed in here there are some soccer kids who try out for nearby clubs when coming to BS. Several at both my kids’ schools.