Appeal Ivy Financial Aid a Second Time?

@thumper1
@politeperson

I don’t know that I would not, or would, choose Ivy 3. I prefer Ivy 1, but if the Ivy 3 finaid is better than Ivy 1, I might choose Ivy 3. My question really is are there any drawbacks to going back to Ivy 1 with a second match request (from Ivy 3)? Could this poison my finaid negotiations with Ivy 1 in later years?