<p>@ RileyJohn: They are probably reading this thread and taking joy in torturing those of us waiting for decisions.</p>
<p>i’m taking my last quarter of o-chem. wassup luckeyg?</p>
<p>uhm The experiment was on separation of a mixtures… And we used Salicylic acid and benzil. I think we used Na2CO3 to neutralized it, but I am not sure… ![]()
the question is Why was the extraction performed with Na2CO3 solutions? wouldn’t plain water have worked as well?</p>
<p>and I answered: No, because polarity of water will separate molecules instead of neutralizing them. Na2CO3 was used to make the solution neutral…</p>
<p>does it sound right? I’ve been focusing way too much on Biology that I am behind in Ochem…:(</p>
<p>You use NaHCO3 to neutralize right?</p>
<p>hmm yeah I was wondering why there was no H, but it’s Na2CO3… not NaHCO3…</p>
<p>I don’t get what is “benzil” though</p>
<p>OK if Na2CO3 is the case, then this salt will react with acid and give you a sodium salicylate (will be in aqueous layer, will be converted back to acid by adding HCl…) and CO2. But please tell me what is “benzil” lol</p>
<p>umm what do you mean like in experiment? It was mixture with Salicylic acid 1:1… and after we mixed with Na2CO3, we separated Benzil in EtOAc and sodium salicylate in water… Then we did some other thing with those solutions… We added HCl to sodium salicylate and we labled beaker carbonate extract.
We added Na2SO4 to the EtOAc solution that we got from earlier experiment and filtered it…</p>
<p>If “benzil” is benzoic acid, this acid is insoluble in water/ aqueous solution plus this is a weak acid, so no H+ is available in aqueous layer —> no reaction with Na2CO3
Salicylic acid is soluble in water –> salicylic acid reacts with Na2CO3 to give salicylate salt and CO2 (salicylic acid has hydrogen bonding…)</p>
<p>you added in Na2SO4 to make your product dry (anhydrous Na2SO4 is always used to suck water from the solution), you filtered it to get salicylic acid</p>
<p>C14H10O2 this is benzil… it doesn’t really look like an acid… BLEH.</p>
<p>ok… i think i kind of got the main point of the experiment… Thank you so much, ntmikey! :)</p>
<p>Ok, so this makes life so much easier, benzil = ketone with 2 benzene rings; it can’t react at all with Na2CO3 and is insoluble in water. This will remain in organic layer.
Salicylic acid reacts with Na2CO3 to give salicylate salt. Salicylate salt reacts with HCl to give back the acid. You used anhydrous Na2SO4 to suck water out of your product. Later filtration gave you crude salicylic acid :)</p>
<p>anytime luckeyg :)</p>
<p>officially never taking organic chemistry.</p>
<p>^ I second that</p>
<p>hyperlite, do you have a facebook? I feel we should become acquainted given the infinitesimal possibility we may one day be sitting in a classroom together.</p>
<p>but but but orgo is fun :)</p>
<p>^ I second that. It’s so much better than bio. I hate effing bio.</p>
<p>I must dissent. I was okay with Biology. Biology is just memorization. Anybody can memorize.</p>