@jym626 , if the parents suggested a car seat, I’d go with that. Have them pick something out and you’ll pay for it. The baby won’t care one way or the other.
Of course, you could assuage your grandparental feelings bay adding a charming outfit in a larger size. Or maybe an age-appropriate board/pop-up book that they don’t have. I don’t know what’s current now, but the Spot books were great when S was a baby.
Push and pull toys–even the classic "popper, which is on sale for less than $6 on Amazon right now.I’m not recommending these in particular, but a few ideas.
You might also start giving a traditional gift like ‘Add a pearl’ necklace or a charm bracelet where you give her a charm every year. It won’t mean much to her now, but when she’s 16 it will.
I think we can agree that there are three types of baby gifts: the super practical (say, a diaper service) the big or bigger-item (crib, car seat, stroller, bassinet) and the meaningful, personal gift – a hand knit sweater, a personalized item, etc. I was very moved when my MIL knit blankets, hats and tiny cardigans, all made with love for her newest-to-be grandchild. Those gifts, and the items she made for my second child, have been treasured, saved and will be passed on to my kids when they become parents. They remain among my most favorite gifts, ever.
I wish they lived in snow country, @abasket and @NEPatsGirl , but they do not. And I wish they lived on a flat terrain, but they do not. S and DIL have a niece and nephew who live nearby and provide lots of hand-me-downs. They are awaiting word as to whether a bigger carseat is in the offing. The nephew may still be using that one.