Do you like band? Are you really interested in chemistry or are you just looking to rack up another AP? Colleges look at your entire application, not just the number of AP classes you took. Don’t tie yourself in knots, or try to create a persona just because you think it will look good on an application. As mom2twogirls says, you’ve covered the basics. Do what will make you happy. You WILL end up at the right school. FYI, since you mention NYU, I know a number of kids who have gone to NYU without taking every AP course they could get their hands on and without 4.0 GPAs.