Have you been to those schools? They are quite different from my recollection. Size, locations, and ‘vibes’ vary greatly. Wellesley is quite different than Georgetown, for instance, in terms of the vibe. And of course as a women’s college (though in a consortium of sorts with Columbia), Barnard is very different from Tufts.
Which type do you prefer…earthy, traditional/conservative?
What size do you prefer?
Urban or suburban?
Which visit gave you the best feeling?
Which has housing all 4 year guaranteed (if that is important)?
What are the classes sizes and how do you feel about that?
Diversity? School spirits? Alumni connections? Are any of those important and if so where do these places fall in that regard?
We looked at some of these schools with our two oldest. They seemed VERY different to me so in that sense you might be able to narrow down your choices after thinking through the questions I listed above. These are some things my kids had to think through.
Finally, what does the money look like? Georgetown does not give merit aid, correct? If you are getting scholarships as some, what are the criteria for the scholarships (to maintain them 4 years)?
You have 4 great choices, and very different choices. What drew you to those schools and which leads the pack now?