best college for a 12 year old

Tests: I did not even know about the SAt, PSAT etc tests-again we are not from the US originally. Duke recommended that he should apply seeing his score. Never was on my book. He just finished a practice ACT: math 32, English 34 and science 34.
And for those who worry: he is not in charge, we as parents will decide. But it may astonish some, we talk and discuss openly all options. If he i.e. does not good on the tests or want to slow down, I am as happy as if he gets a full scholar ship to any great university. If he is not behind it, there will be no good outcome. I am only a boxing coach, but that translate from the sports world as well. Parents pushing kids does not lead to world class and even if-it is not how we see parenting.
Maturity: he is 12 . plain simple, loves goofing around with his friends etc. Also he helped me with my youth social programs in the last 3 years a lot. With my wife he volunteers regularly with pet rescues. I know many hs kids who volunteer sitting in some animal shelters playing with their phones. We lived already in three different countries and I can assure you NYC is no "big city shocker ".
Just to assure everybody: we do not want to break any records, do not want to send him somewhere alone, we (and he) are totally aware that a gift in learning is only one part of life. Stretching it until 17 won´t be good or feasible in my opinion.
Dual enrollment won´t be accepted outside of Fl. AP tests are only ones a year and he did instead multiple CLEP-intellectually these lower college classes def. work for him. Surely in a tier 1 college those might be harder.

  1. we will see how the testing goes
  2. we will travel as soon as covid allows and see on spot
  3. colleges will decide anyways at the end what options are on the table
    Community college classes for a while are no worries at all and totally forgot: NYC due to his love of museums and plays, antiques and book stores, libraries etc…
    Thanks again to all

If this is the PSAT 8/9, it’s a much easier test than the regular exam.

Maybe this will provide some clarity. Percentiles vary by test and grade level. Here is the PSAT 8/9 percentile chart: https://collegereadiness.collegeboard.org/pdf/psat-8-9-understanding-scores-fall.pdf On the PSAT 8/9, 1250 would be 99th User percentile for an 8th grader.

The PSAT 8/9 has a lower ceiling than the SAT and PSAT, yet is designed to theoretically show what a student would have gotten on the SAT if they had taken it that same day. In other words, the 1250 on the PSAT 8/9 indicates that, in theory, the student would have gotten a 1250 on the SAT on that day.

On the SAT a score of 1250 would be 81st percentile. https://collegereadiness.collegeboard.org/pdf/understanding-sat-scores.pdf (On the 11th grade PSAT, 1250 would be 87th percentile.)

I hope this helps with the big picture. For such a talented kid, it doesn’t make sense to me to take the real SAT until he’s scoring >1500 on timed full practice tests, because he will get there eventually without trying very hard, simply due to the passage of time and increase in academic skills along the way. (The only reason to take the SAT sooner would be for entry to a special program like Duke TIP.)

Then NYC, with 8th grade “homeschool” where you dedicate a lot of time to museums of all sorts (big and small), plays, etc. in addition to a 3000 German class at Columbia and preparing for the specialized HS exam.
[Do not think the exam will be a cinch regardless of his skills and intelligence. It’s designed to eliminate/sift out. Only kids who are at least 2 or 3 years ahead can even attempt it.]
HS at Stuy (or Brooklyn Latin) isn’t like HS where you are, or high school about anywhere. It’s designed to provide a challenge for kids who learn easily and have rarely been challenged before, as well as for kids who have sought challenges and want more.
It doesn’t matter if he’s ready to graduate from regular high school.
It’s a bit as if he’d completed precalculus and that’s where his HS stops, whereas there’s a high school where discrete math, differential equations, etc, are the norm. There’ll be placement tests to ensure he’s not in a class below his current level. He won’t be starting in Algebra 1 and German 1. He’ll be taking the classes that challenge him, with teachers who challenge and support him, and peers who challenge and support him. This won’t be holding him back. (Or, if after a year you see it is, it’s simple: switch out.)
More importantly:
He’ll learn AND he’ll be with peers. Perhaps for the first time in his life, he’ll be able to vigorously discuss Amulet and Aramehic with a 13 year old. [replace this with whatever applies]
That feeling of being part of a group is hugely important for gifted kids, because PG kids feel isolated regardless of what their parents do. They gravitate toward older students but need peers.
Has he participated in the Duke TIP summer camps?
If he likes Latin, see whether he can start on Ancient Greek. It’s got cases (like German) but, like Korean, involves a different alphabet and a different way of thinking/writing. In my opinion, it’s also more elegant than Latin (although I’m no good at either language so I admit that appreciation is purely subjective :p)
Also: yes, there’s a huge difference between colleges, especially for Humanities. When the time comes, you really want him enrolled at a top college. There’s no “do over” in the US: once you’ve got a BA, you aren’t eligible for financial aid anymore, and most top schools don’t admit people for a second BA.
If he can get into Columbia as a non degree student as a 13 year old, good for him, but check very carefully what it entails and how it impacts future college.
Also, when choosing languages, look into the Critical Languages list. (Another reason Korean was on my earlier list, beside being an accessible challenge and a good jumping off point, is that it’s a critical language.) If his talent is for languages, that list would matter, and later the NSLI-Youth.

Folks, the OP has already stated that his kid has completed a practice ACTs in the 30’s.

An IQ test, however imperfect, would still be a much better gauge of a child’s giftedness than the standardized achievement tests.

This is so important, it’s not just whether a child is “mature” enough for college. Being able to be with similar kids of their own age is a huge boost.

very thoughtful–thanks a lot MYOS1634!!
He was at DUke Tip camps and he was the last 3 years at the Gifted Academy in FTL-as often in these programs they truly try to offer advanced classes but due to lack of enough students in one field-most of his advancement was online via FLVS. He did Algebra, Geo, Precalculus.
The peer group is surely the main wish we would have on our list!Other than EEP in Cal State the other programs would all have older kids around 16 and as I mentioned before, that might be harder to be 12 with 16 year olds than with 20 up. That´s why we think the some college classes and educate with NYC culture offers and see if he is ready for full time after that might be in his best interest. We will also wait what Duke says, they started the dilemma with the TIP program :slight_smile: and are very supportive!

again I appreciate your input and that helps a lot!
The Latin school and Sty as Davidson sound fantastic. Unluckily as we are from Fl he can not participate in the test for NYC, if we now move and he takes it in November he does not qualify as he already has finished 10th on regular public school with honor classes. Probably we use the “gap” time for him to see the City get enrolled at a CUny or Community college and we see 2021 what´s happening. Step by step.
I learned a lot-thank you all

Columbia GS (gap year required along the line) and Harvard Extension (no gap year required & very much not the traditional college experience) are both nontraditional options.