best colleges in the south for my daughter with a 31 ACT/4.0 GPA

If you don’t qualify for need based aid and your budget is 55k, you will need pretty substantial merit aid, and many of the schools mentioned have very limited merit aid.

Congrats to your D for her hard work and success in HS!

Agree with @warblersrule about difference between W&L and Davidson in terms of student demographics, climate and Greek scene. Also, Davidson is not an easier admit than W&L (they have had comparable admit rates over the years) it’s just that Davidson puts less focus on test scores so its range is a little lower.

Run the Net Price Calculator at the privates to see what your EFC would be. If you qualify, at many privates you could get to $55k with work/study and the federal loan amount (about $7500 a year) – not sure if you’re willing to do loans though. Davidson is one of the few ‘no loan’ colleges so they would make that up in aid, fyi.

I think Georgia and College of Charleston are both good suggestions. Also Rhodes and Richmond if she wants something smaller.

Wake Forest could work for your daughter ED, but merit aid would not be offered with her stats. Wake just released their 2019-2020 Common Data Set and their ACT midrange is now 30-33. She would get substantial merit aid at Rhodes and Sewanee, both great schools, and should be an easy admit.

Thank you everyone for all suggestions including such great insights into the schools! I appreciate how supportive all of these comments are and am so impressed with how knowledgeable all of you are!!

re test optional for 2020-2021.<<<<<<<

OP’s kid does have an official test though, sometimes these test scores are on your transcript and you are not able to get it removed.