Best Math Schools Beyond the Ones on all the Top 10 Lists?

I’m not sure how you’re ranking your top 10 list, but the UCs and Michigan are at least as strong as all of those colleges in math, at both the undergraduate and graduate levels. I would certainly concede that the UCs are rarely a good bargain for OOS students.

RPI, Case Western, U Rochester, Northeastern, and Boston U could be worth a look. Although it’s almost as selective as some of the Ivies these days, USC is another possibility.

Almost uniquely among public universities, UNC Chapel Hill meets the financial need of all domestic students. The cap on OOS students makes getting in difficult, however.

You have great stats. If you apply widely and have good essays and extracurriculars, I think you should be able to get into at least one of the hyper-selective universities.