Completely agree! Our school gives “customized” advice and one kid was told just SAT, because got 99th on that in 10th(97th on pre-ACT unprepped as all 10th scores are, but didn’t come close to finishing–major timing issues) and she took the advice: did SAT only because it was a better fit “naturally” and there are some schools that either require or “encourage” ALL scores to be sent (even in the new “Test Optional” era). Winging it is not a good plan. Second kid had higher and more closely correlated scores (99+ on both) in 10th, was advised to do both early in junior yr, and she will likely submit both because one test has a perfect math and one has a perfect reading(and almost- perfect on rest). It really is dependent on the student!