<p>Our son applied to Bucknell, Richmond, and Miami. Although Miami is a terrific school, in terms of academics I don’t think it is on par with either Bucknell or Richmond - our son considered it one of his “safer” schools and was admitted EA with a significant merit aid package.
He really wrestled between Bucknell and Richmond for ED2 - he took the time and energy to visit each school several times, sit in on classes, go to basketball games, hang out with current students, etc. For a myriad of reasons along with gut instinct, he knew Bucknell was the right choice for him. He confidently signed the ED contract, sent in his application to Bucknell and was accepted in February.
My advice to you is if at all practicable try revisit these schools again this month - picture yourself living at each of them for 4 years - do the kids seem happy? are the class sizes small? how is the food? does it seem like a pressure cooker environment or a healthy balance of academics and fun? Pay close attention to your instinct because it will steer you in the right direction every time. It doesn’t really matter what anyone on CC thinks - we are all individuals with our own preferences and priorities. Good luck - what an exciting time in your life!</p>