<p>I agree that both have flaws. However, my point is that I still have seen no reason to think that BW is less flawed than USNews. Both are flawed, but it seems to me that BW is more flawed. The intense fluctuations of the BW rankings calls it into question - true B-school quality does not fluctuate as much as BW would have you believe. </p>
<p>Combining historic averages is a reasonable thing to do, but if you do so, then you have to combine the historic averages of both BW and USNews, not just BW. I used to have the historic averages of USNews, I will post it once I find it again.</p>