It’s really not random although it may appear so if you look at a few colleges based on your knowledge of three or four high schools.
I think you’d be better served by ignoring stats for now, and focusing on what you want out of college life- the vibe, the culture, etc.
And for what it’s worth, my MIT kid had no research or olympiads/competitions. So you can’t really extrapolate from what you are observing in the kids you know who get in to MIT and apply it broadly.
And I’m still confused about what you are looking for. Williams is nothing like Case; Colby is nothing like Cal Tech; Hamilton is nothing like U Chicago. In general, kids who are excited about NYU also apply to BU, GW, Columbia. Kids who are interested in MIT and Caltech apply to RPI, WPI, Georgia Tech, Olin, Cooper Union etc. So I don’t see a lot of overlap among these schools which is why I’m struggling to help you figure out your “why” and build a strong case for “Admit me! I’d add so much!”
Colby and NYU are almost solely there because we’re a feeder school, whether or not that’s for the best. They aren’t schools I’d naturally seek out, and there are schools at their level of competitiveness that I like more. That being said, the raw resources and facilities the schools have still make them compelling if the boost from being at a feeder makes them fall into a significantly less competitive category. The same goes for Hamilton with legacy; I don’t dislike the school, but I wouldn’t naturally apply to it.
Maybe that’s something that should change, but until I find schools with comparable personal admit rates where the fit outweighs the resources available at these more competitive schools, I think it’s unlikely I sub them out.
Colleges admit students, not high schools.
At my kids HS (just to show you how the “feeder” dynamic might work) Harvard always accepted three; Yale always accepted three. Princeton a little more idiosyncratic but generally one of two. Then one year- catastrophe Yale accepted none. Harvard accepted two. Princeton accepted nobody.
The students were horrified. How could this happen when we’re a “feeder” to HYP? So the rising seniors were trying to read the tea leaves, frantic to assess what/when/how. And then Harvard accepted two- again. Yale- none. Princeton- none.
So just as the dust was settling and kids were resetting their expectations, four seniors were rumored to be applying early to Harvard, a bunch to Yale, a bunch to Princeton. And by all accounts, the Harvard applicants were absolute stars in every possible way. Harvard took all four, Yale took nobody, Princeton took nobody.
And then the NEXT year (when one of my kids was a senior, so knew the class pretty well), Harvard went back to three (where I think it has stuck for the last few years), Yale went to one or two, Princeton MAYBE one every few years.
So “feeder” isn’t an official term or contract by the colleges. It’s backwards looking. It’s great that you are getting a rigorous education at a school which is well known by a wide range of colleges. But I’d be dropping Colby like a stone based on what you’ve posted. It is a fine institution but doesn’t seem at all what you are looking for. If that IS what you are looking for, check out Bowdoin, Trinity, Conn College, Skidmore, Vassar.
What '‘Raw resources” does Colby have that two dozen LAC’s do not have- many of which seem more aligned with your actual interests???
Bowdoin DOES have those resources; I’m just saying for my individual odds. We have a 78% acceptance rate at Colby and only a 27% at Bowdoin, so they’re just not in the same category there. If we had an equal acceptance rate at these schools, then I wouldn’t be thinking about it, but that’s just not the way it works. Also, it doesn’t have any kind of supplements or anything additional and costs $0 to apply, so it really is just an extra layer of security for a school I would be fine going to, and I don’t really see a problem with that.
That may be true but when parents are paying $50-100K annual tuition & fees to educate their children at these private schools, they are looking for some type of perceived guarantee of their kids gaining acceptance to top-20 universities & liberal arts colleges. In CulturedMemes’s private high school, the guidance department could be encouraging their students to apply to many colleges (>20) to maintain & expand the list of college acceptances for their school profile, regardless of whether the student enrolls or not. It looks better for any private school to boast recent acceptances to all Ivy League universities & Caltech, MIT, & Stanford plus most or all top-10 or 20 liberal arts colleges to continue attracting incoming students & their parents with pockets full of money.
That is something I didn’t even consider! You might be right, and I’ll think about that a bit more when finalizing my list. To be fair, though, for yield protection’s sake, it may make less sense for them to do that, but I’m not an expert.
@maijem11 makes an excellent point. I’d encourage you to look deeper and wider than the schools your guidance counselors seem to be steering you towards. Also, they don’t care about a college’s yield.
Find the schools for YOU. Apply to those. Don’t particularly feel drawn to NYU or Hamilton? Don’t apply there. There are so many schools that will have what you are looking for. Good luck to you!
Among the many things that the elite private schools in my area do well– is the quality of their college advising, and specifically how they prevent/avoid the “bunching” problem. At some of the large local public HS’s, if 35 kids decide they are applying to Dartmouth, the answer is “good luck to you”. If 25 kids decide that Harvard is their “dream” school, they might get a “you also need a couple of matches and safeties”.
That’s not how it works at the top private schools I know. The Dartmouth wannabees are encouraged to spread a wide net. The 4 or 5 plausible Dartmouth admittees are encouraged to apply early; the rest are sent home with “you’d love UVM, you should check out Middlebury, Skidmore is in a gorgeous part of NY State and they love students like you”. The 25 Harvard dreamers get sifted (to the aggravation of both kids and parents) into three buckets. The “Get going on your Harvard essays; btw, Ms. White who taught you in American History last year writes very compelling recommendations” bucket. The “Wow, I’m impressed with how ambitious you are. Have you looked at UVA, Haverford, Lehigh, Denison, Miami Ohio? Let’s keep Harvard as your reach while we find some more likely admits for you” bucket. And then the third bucket– “Do you know any of the three kids from our school who are at Holy Cross right now? I’m sure they’d love to show you around when you visit. And if you haven’t seen Clark yet, you can do that the next day if you go for a weekend.”
Paying over 50K for tuition– even at Horace Mann, Dalton, Latin School in Chicago, Groton, etc. does not guarantee you a seat at a top 20. The trick these schools use is to spread out the class– reduce the bunching- which means everyone gets something which is a fit for them. I remember when Muhlenberg suddenly showed up on every private school kid’s list if they were musical, and when Denison appeared out of nowhere for East Coast prep school families. Penn is no longer interested in taking 20 of your students? Better find a substitute.
You’re right. A Horace Mann, Dalton, or Groton education doesn’t guarantee anything but their school profile better not omit any big top-20 college names else a parent will take their child & their $50K tuition payment elsewhere. A smart buyer doing their homework will demand this kind of information.
top prep schools, IME, keep applications low to keep relationships and keep yield ot schools high…many even restrict the number of kids can apply too.. It would be very interesting if doing opposite (could be though I don’t know where this kid goes and there may be some new trend).
And I personally have never seen a top-tier HS school list “acceptances” it is always matriculation…
Blossom’s post is terrific, to truly focus on what you want from a college and not just the chance of admission.
Another aspect is to think about travel. Since you are from CA, and have east coast colleges on your list, consider how far a school is from an airport.
100%. I don’t have any personal experience with these schools (I know plenty on CC do) but a friend’s kids went to one of the elite boarding schools. One ended up at Syracuse and one at GWU. Both fine schools but certainly not top ranked. The one who went to GW applied ED,which probably underscores the second sentence in the extract I quoted above.
If you may want to pursue engineering, I would eliminate schools that don’t offer it, yes even the legacy. This way you keep options open. Schools like Union, Lafayette and Bucknell are fine LACs that has engineering as does Swarthmore.
The UCs and UW won’t see your 1550 - small chance UW does.
You likely have some acceptances but if you want a top flight Physics school that’s a sure admit, where is U of Arizona ?