@ShredderRob If it’s any consolation, I have similar stats to your daughter—35 ACT, 3.93 GPA, 11 APs, I went to a very well known, renowned private school, etc, etc—while I may have been accepted to Carleton, I was rejected from Haverford and waitlisted at Davidson even after being accepted to schools such as Swarthmore, MIT, Georgetown, and now Carleton, and I have likely letters from Yale and Brown. So, it was quite surprising when I was rejected from Haverford/WL at Davidson. I have no doubt your D will get into some wonderful places. I think we can all agree than college admissions are a complete gamble, and often times the results are very unexpected. Best of luck to you and your D!