<p>Virginiaman:</p>
<p>As far as comparisons to Amherst and Williams are concerned, the superficial differences are pretty obvious. Carleton will offer similar weather until Jan/Feb when Northfield will present colder temperatures but less snow. Williams will be the most campus-centric and isolated of the three, Carleton offer the best access to city attractions, and Amherst offer the greatest breadth of off campus activities within a near-in (15 minutes or so) driving radius of school. Varsity sports will be a larger priority at Williams/Amherst (Ultimate being the one exception at Carleton). Almost all Carls are involved in intramurals (to a degree rarely found among peers). PE electives (from Tae Kwon Do to scuba to rock climbing) and the well-equipped gym are also similarly very, very popular.</p>
<p>As far as the student body is concerned, the “quirkiness” of Carleton is often misunderstood. It defines not so much a student body that’s so “different” in substance, but rather a student body that is so tolerant of “different” that being true to yourself and freely expressing yourself is refreshingly endemic. This is the ANTI poseur school with an ANTI “look at me, aren’t I fascinating when I do this” student body. Posing is, in fact, one of the few things NOT tolerated here.</p>
<p>As far as tolerance is concerned, you’re right in seeing Carleton’s midwest location as a defining influence. Despite the clearly liberal leanings of the student body, this is not Berkeley of the '60s. Conservative political views may well put you in the minority, but they can be (and are) expressed freely without fear of stoning. Traditional religion is deeply respected and regularly practiced with participation in weekend services, clubs, and group meetings common.</p>
<p>So why make the trip to Northfield from Virginia?<br>
You will have trouble finding another school that so well marries such serious academics and seriousness of purpose with so much serious fun. Students love their time here. Encouraged to grow in such an accepting atmosphere, immersed for four years in a midwestern/heartland non-competitive/supportive community, and encouraged to prioritize a sense of responsibility to the greater good - this is a pretty wonderfully unique place.</p>