Hamilton and Middlebury are reaches for all due to low acceptance rates.
How much is your budget? If it’s high enough, you might be able to find some financial safeties that offer large automatic merit scholarships, such as University of Alabama and others.
Most of your list so far are mid size universities, not LACs. You might add more of both sizes to your list. For matches, look further down in rankings for schools with reasonable acceptance rates, generally beyond the top 50 national universities, with a few exceptions like the University of Rochester. Use the Net Price Calculator for all schools of interest to make sure they’d be in budget.