Florida State has a remarkably good religious studies program (I’m most familiar with its strengths in American religious history). Your overall GPA might make it a difficult admit, even with the upward trend. So if that’s what you think you might want to do, you might consider starting at a more auto-admit campus (80%+ admissions rate) or a CC and transfer to FSU if your interest in religious studies continues.
I would not recommend looking into New College. The politicization of that campus in recent years means that it is not what it once was, especially in the humanities. I suspect that in the future, this will hurt grad school applicants coming out of that school (worth keeping in mind if you are considering graduate study).