I’m not @NiceUnparticularMan, but below is a pretty extensive list of schools you might want to consider.
Extremely Likely (80-99+%)
-
Allegheny (PA ): About 1200 undergrads
-
Baldwin Wallace (OH): About 2800 undergrads
-
Drew (NJ): About 1600 undergrads
-
Elizabethtown (PA ): About 1900 undergrads
-
Emmanuel (MA): About 2k undergrads
-
Ithaca (NY): About 4400 undergrads
-
Juniata (PA ): About 1200 undergrads
-
Loyola Maryland: About 4k undergrads
-
Muhlenberg (PA ): About 1800 undergrads
-
Saint Anselm (NH): About 2100 undergrads
-
Saint Joseph’s (PA ): About 4800 undergrads
-
Saint Michael’s (VT): About 1200 undergrads
-
Siena (NY): About 3500 undergrads
-
SUNY Geneseo (NY): About 3900 undergrads
-
Susquehanna (PA ): About 2200 undergrads
-
Wheaton (MA): About 1800 undergrads
Likely (60-79%)
-
Clark (MA): About 2400 undergrads
-
Dickinson (PA ): About 2200 undergrads
-
Gettysburg (PA ): About 2200 undergrads
-
Hobart William Smith (NY): About 1600 undergrads
-
Ohio Wesleyan: About 1500 undergrads
-
Providence (RI): About 4200 undergrads
-
St. Lawrence (NY): About 2100 undergrads
-
The College of Wooster (OH): About 1900 undergrads
Toss-Up (40-59%)
-
Brandeis (MA): About 3700 undergrads
-
College of the Holy Cross (MA): About 3k undergrads
-
Connecticut College: About 2k undergrads
-
Fairfield (CT): About 5k undergrads
-
Franklin and Marshall (PA ): About 1900 undergrads
-
Lafayette (PA ): About 2800 undergrads
-
Oberlin (OH): About 3k undergrads
-
Trinity (CT): About 2200 undergrads
-
Union (NY): About 2100 undergrads
Lower Probability (20-39%)
-
Denison (OH): About 2400 undergrads
-
Kenyon (OH): About 2200 undergrads
-
Vassar (NY): About 2500 undergrads
-
Wesleyan (CT): About 3100 undergrads
Low Probability (less than 20%)
The list I provided is pretty large, in part, because I don’t have a great sense of what it is you’re looking for in a college. You’ve got extremely urban schools with rural schools, schools with small, medium, and large sizes, the bulk of your list is schools in the northeast and Ohio, but then you’ve got California, Georgia, and Tennessee there, too. Some have a reputation for being a very athletic-y vibe while others are more nerdy. Some have lots of enthusiasm for intercollegiate sports while others have none. Some have Greek life that plays an important role, and others have none.
If you can let us know more about what you want out of your college experience, we can provide more targeted suggestions (and perhaps highlight or eliminate schools on the list I just shared).