I agree it is problematic to treat American as a Likely with your numbers, as they may waitlist or even reject you if they think there is very little chance of you yielding (and realistically–isn’t that right?).
Like others, I think diversifying beyond your current Reaches into some suitable Target/Match, or possibly more Likelies, is probably a good idea.
To me, it is possibly helpful to focus on Arabic. Good departments for IR and French are pretty common, but serious departments for the study of Arabic and Middle Eastern cultures are maybe a little more of a distinguishing feature.
In that spirit, one college I like to recommend to people with such an interest (and good numbers) is Bucknell. Bucknell is normally better known for things like being an LAC with business and engineering. However, it turns out Bucknell also has a really robust Arabic and Arab World Studies program:
You can do a full major, or a minor. They have dedicated study abroad, and an Arabic Club.
Kenyon is then another college with a really robust Arabic program:
One of the cool things about their program is the different track options:
The Arabic program offers four years of instruction in language, literature, and culture. Students may minor or major in Arabic. We offer three different tracks to declaring Arabic as a major: one-language (Arabic) track; two-language (Arabic and another MLL language) track; and the interdisciplinary (Arabic and another discipline) track.
Not surprisngly, French is one of the other MLL languages if you decide to go in that direction:
Obviously you need to check the NPCs on these sorts of colleges. Both also do have some merit, though. And without promising anything, I think they could see your profile as worth chasing after.