Chance Me/Advice: Low [3.4] GPA, Above Average [1600] SAT + EC, Recruitable Athlete [NJ resident]

Is your sport an individual (as part of a team) sport, or a team sport? If it’s an individual sport with times, you can see how you compare to current team members at the schools you are looking at. If it’s a ranked sport, you can do the same. If it’s a team sport, is it a specialized position? If that is a case, spreading a wide net to see who is in need of filling that spot can help.

Where do people on the national team you play for tend to end up? At any of the schools you’re looking at ? If you see a big trend, chances are they just want your grades to be within a certain range. For one-offs, grades probably matter more. As someone else suggested, working with your national team coach would be very beneficial.

1 Like

OP: You need to reach out to the coaches of your sport at each university that is of interest to you.

I think that I know your sport. If correct, the good news is that the number of scholarships (which are almost always partial scholarship awards) permitted at D 1 universities has more than tripled in the last year or two.

If I have correctly guessed your sport, then top D III schools (there are no athletic scholarships offered by D III schools or by Ivy League schools) might be approved by your mother. Consider Middlebury, Bowdoin, U Chicago, Amherst, Tufts, Williams College, Wash & Lee, & Colby College.

Also, consider the College of William & Mary–which is a great school academically.

Whether or not a school offers athletic scholarships, coaches still recruit and typically have some pull with admissions–so if a coach really wants you, then your GPA may be adequate.

3 Likes

OP: Another avenue to an elite university might be through a PG (post high school graduate year) year at Phillips Exeter Acadamy (New Hampshire), Phillips Academy at Andover ( Massachusetts),or at Choate Rosemary Hall (Connecticut). A PG year would be an opportunity to improve your grades and to better prepare for the academic demands of an elite university or college.

Culver Academies in Indiana & IMG in Florida might be of interest for a PG year if serious about your sport. The coaches at both schools are well connected with university coaches.

2 Likes

I’d focus exclusively on the athletic recruiting path at this point, with the urgency others have suggested.

You can circle back in the summer and fall to figure out safety, match, etc, if recruiting doesn’t work out.

Sit down today with your mom and run the NPC at Princeton and at least a few other schools on that list. Do you qualify for aid? Can your mom afford that amount? How? If your mom doesn’t want you to see her financials she can do this alone.

This is a key filter. Coaches at the very generous need-based aid schools will want to know if you can afford to attend. There is no point wasting your time talking to the Yale coach if your mom can’t explain to you how she will pay. If you will qualify for good aid, then you have a lot more confidence pursuing things with some of those schools. If you don’t qualify for aid and can’t realistically afford those schools, then focus on schools that can offer athletic aid (not Ivies or D3).

If things look good financially, contact all Ivy coaches by tomorrow. A short, simple email. I’m a recent convert to the sport , on the nat team, state champ. I attend X HS and have a 3.4 gpa and X SAT. Hoping to learn more about the program at X, including the recruiting process. Wondering if you’re still recruiting for my class and if so, is there a time when we could chat? [ETA: include your cell# !]

Then move on to non-Ivies on Tuesday, etc. Continue expanding the net every day.

I’m a fan of doing the recruiting forms with an email because sometimes emails fall through the cracks.

You should have a good sense of things by the end of the week. Circle back next week if you’ve heard nothing at a given program.

Let coaches tell you if the GPA is a problem. Be prepared to send them a transcript.

Rutgers is a good school. Don’t exclude opportunities like that. Keep the net cast wide until you have real options to choose from.

Keep in mind that recruiting in most sports is international, so you aren’t just competing against US recruits.

5 Likes

Also note that the reason the Princeton NPC has come up multiple times is because Princeton is usually the most generous college in the country with respect to need-based financial aid. If Princeton NPC doesn’t provide sufficient need-based aid, it is highly unlikely that any other college will provide more than that. It is not necessarily recommendations that Princeton is the best college for you—just that they provide a good metric for financial aid evaluations.

Note that every college has their own formula, so you do have to run the NPC for all colleges of interest. Don’t use the myintution site but the college’s own, individualized NPC.

The above does not apply to merit or athletic scholarships— just need-based aid.

Also, if your parents own a business or are divorced, the NPC may not be as accurate.

4 Likes

I would reach out right away.

My daughter attended one of the schools on your list. She was not a recruited athlete.

Her college roommate played a sport for many years at a very high level. She wanted to play on the club team but didn’t make it. D1 can be hyper-competitive even at the club level. She eventually joined a team organized by the dorm.

My colleague’s daughter spoke to coaches very early on (same college). I seem to recall visits back and forth, tours of the facilities, lots of wining and dining, etc. A few schools were interested.

I think you need to get going on this. I also think you need to figure out the finances, what financial awards the schools would provide, etc….

I would also try to firm up Rutgers and any aid.

1 Like

No guarantees but I think UF might consider you without being a recruited athlete. If you do get recruited, I think your SATs will carry you through to a possible commitment to several top 50 schools (including some on your list). I am glad your situation has seen some improvement. If you share more about the sport and recruiting, I can probably offer more.

1 Like

If parents will be divorced, be sure to find out if the college will require both of their finances. If a college does, be sure to include both of their finances in the NPC. Princeton’s NPC mentions that up front, but for many other colleges, you have dig around their financial aid web pages to figure that out.

Most of the prestige private schools except Chicago and Vanderbilt do want both divorced parents’ finances.

You can also apply for a waiver, but it is not necessarily obvious whether it will be granted at each college.

Given the student has, based on what’s shared, little rigor, UF might be one of the hardest schools on the list because the GPA will likely fall well below UFs levels - which are driven up by Honors and AP classes and As in those classes.

She should let the coaches decide this. They know what will get through admissions and what won’t.

Athletic recruiting is a different process and she should focus exclusively on that right now. If it doesn’t work out she can put together a list over the summer that considers general admissions.

2 Likes

That I agree with. The high level athletics is where it’s at admission wise so OP needs to start there. Obviously many athletes attend schools that wouldn’t accept them otherwise.

1 Like

You’ve asked for information on whether your gpa can be ‘okay’ if you are a recruited athlete. Generally, yes, if a coach wants you and gives you support through admissions, having a 3.4ish gpa works. Other things will be considered too, of course, like if your academics fit with the school (you probably wouldn’t be accepted to MIT).

Athletes are different. The coach has a lot of pull, but most of the schools you’ve listed are D1 and the teams are competitive, and you are VERY late to the game for recruiting in most sports. You may be in a special position (goalie, pitcher) and that coach may already have filled the position for your year. Some coaches only recruit from summer camps or off teams playing in leagues they know. Some schools only allow a coach to support 2-3 athletes through admission, especially in minor sports (you said it isn’t basketball or track).

Look at the current rosters of the team you’d be part of and see the backgrounds of the other players. HS, club teams, awards, state championships? You can get a lot of info about what the coach might be looking for.

I do think you need a better reason for your gpa than that you just weren’t that interested in school. College is school. The coaches don’t want to worry about your grades while you are in school, about your not being able to play that week because you didn’t make grades or because you can’t miss a test. My daughter’s coach got notice if she missed a class (yes, in COLLEGE) and it was a big deal.

So get recruited and then come back and ask for advice. If you are recruited, it changes the game. We can’t get you recruited, or even say if the Stanford team in your sport would be better or easier to get on than the one at JHU (which is D3). You can also read the Athlete Recruits forum here on CC and it might help you with how hard or easy it is to get recruited. Get help from your coaches, both your hs team and the national team you played for. Most of them have been through the process themselves, with their own kids, or with kids they’ve coached. They have connections, they know coaches and assistant coaches on college teams. Once my daughter was recruited, her college coach reached out to the hs/club coaches and at one time their were 5 players from her former teams on her college team. They form connections.

Correct me if I’m wrong though, the student can get into a school bit then there’s still the money issue - potentially.

So I still would run the NPCs.

i estimated a 3.5+. UF lives for the test, from my experience.

A 4.5-4.7 gpa given a .5 lift for Honors and +1 for AP. OP won’t be close and has acknowledged school wasn’t a huge focus.

Of course OP can try any school.

Hopefully they get the budget situation handled first as well as the academics.

I do not understand what you are saying about a 4.5-4.7

That’s the Florida 25/75 gpa using the unweighted on a 4.0 unweighted scale with a .5 Honors and 1 point AP bump. I don’t see OP being close.

Even if they could get in, is there scholarship money for the sport. Otherwise, by the time OP goes with the OOS tuition hikes coming, it will be $50k+ with need aid unlikely.

it is very hard for Florida to reject 1550+ kids. i have never seen it happen. and with all honors freshman year, the weighted is likely better than 3.5. money is a different issue, so i defer to the experts.

1 Like

The OP doesn’t seem to care about scholarship money if the sport can help her get into the school. Depending on the sport, there might not be much money at ANY school, the ones that the parent will pay for and the ones the parent wouldn’t pay.

This doesn’t seem to be a headcount sport so it’s very unlikely that the scholarship will cover a lot. The benefit is getting into the schools.

1 Like

Yes, we just don’t know the finances. I hope mom has the money because it sounds like $10k or she’ll find a way. I love how people just find a way.

But hopefully the student can get to the bottom of it. I think academically, without coach help and right now there is none, OP is 0 for on this list.