I’d focus exclusively on the athletic recruiting path at this point, with the urgency others have suggested.
You can circle back in the summer and fall to figure out safety, match, etc, if recruiting doesn’t work out.
Sit down today with your mom and run the NPC at Princeton and at least a few other schools on that list. Do you qualify for aid? Can your mom afford that amount? How? If your mom doesn’t want you to see her financials she can do this alone.
This is a key filter. Coaches at the very generous need-based aid schools will want to know if you can afford to attend. There is no point wasting your time talking to the Yale coach if your mom can’t explain to you how she will pay. If you will qualify for good aid, then you have a lot more confidence pursuing things with some of those schools. If you don’t qualify for aid and can’t realistically afford those schools, then focus on schools that can offer athletic aid (not Ivies or D3).
If things look good financially, contact all Ivy coaches by tomorrow. A short, simple email. I’m a recent convert to the sport , on the nat team, state champ. I attend X HS and have a 3.4 gpa and X SAT. Hoping to learn more about the program at X, including the recruiting process. Wondering if you’re still recruiting for my class and if so, is there a time when we could chat? [ETA: include your cell# !]
Then move on to non-Ivies on Tuesday, etc. Continue expanding the net every day.
I’m a fan of doing the recruiting forms with an email because sometimes emails fall through the cracks.
You should have a good sense of things by the end of the week. Circle back next week if you’ve heard nothing at a given program.
Let coaches tell you if the GPA is a problem. Be prepared to send them a transcript.
Rutgers is a good school. Don’t exclude opportunities like that. Keep the net cast wide until you have real options to choose from.
Keep in mind that recruiting in most sports is international, so you aren’t just competing against US recruits.