Well said, Dad. I might note that Wisconsin also has cold winters. 
Let me add that UW is in a terrific city which is also the state capital and UW is big enough to have lots going on just at the university itself. Your point was well taken about Hanover being rural and isolated. When I’ve driven out of town there, it always felt like I was in Dogpatch within 5 miles in any direction. Yet, I do know students, including one currently there, who have been very happy with their 4 years at Dartmouth. So, your point about “fit” is well taken.