Interesting, because if you don’t believe that someone’s ECs are what they say, why would you believe that they won a specific award? Sure, some can be verified, but some can’t.
I would want to see well rounded kids- who participate in an activity, who add value to the community, etc. I’d be hopeful that they speak the truth. I know my kids did.
That said, neither of us (well, i’m not) are AOs - so can’t really be sure what people are looking for.
While I know some awards show mastery over society, I’d much rather have a kid who plays in the band, walks dogs, does meals on wheels, helps a refugee family as my daughter did at home and is leading a team to do in College…then someone who can say they won a math competition…that’s great, but what are they doing to help society.
But again, i’m not an AO - so what I think doesn’t matter too much.