If you got an A in PE how did that lower your GPA ?
I think you know you have a strong chance.
I’d encourage you, assuming you become an NMF, to look at schools that will literally throw themselves at you. For example, at Alabama you’d earn tuition and housing for five years so grad school. Just one example. There are others. It’s a golden ticket you can take advantage of (NMF) if you do desire. If you don’t that’s ok but in case you’re not aware, it really is a gift these schools provide to the select few.
I think your odds are good at UND. Your not being catholic won’t matter ( I don’t think) but it likely will matter on the day to day life you live so that’s more for you to think about than the admissions committee. .
Congrats on all you’ve done.