Congratulations to your academic results - a 3.8 UW GPA is very respectable, and you’ll likely have good opportunities at many great schools!
Nothing here “screams” Ivy League. By itself, NHS, SG, Tutoring, 4 APs and the SAT score, are not going to stand out at all among the many other applicants to those colleges. These schools can’t accommodate >90% of students with near-perfect ACT or SAT scores and very distinct extracurriculars.
So you would need to show an admissions officer something significantly more “intriguing” in your essay/extracurriculars, to elevate those chances from “unlikely” to “reach”.
Certainly, keep the dream alive, but I’d suggest not to invest too much emotions and effort, but rather work on your list of likely’s.