ED2 will boost your chances compared to EA, though the ED2 acceptance rate is lower than ED1, as told to me directly by the admissions office. (They didn’t say how much lower). I would submit your 1410 because it’s closer to their range than your GPA, so relative to your GPA your test score probably helps. 89 is pretty low for a GPA. My sophomore was admitted ED1 with a 92/3.7 unweighted and hers was the second lowest GPA admitted from our school relative to the prior 5 years. They do admit A LOT of jersey kids so can you see (e.g. in Naviance) what a typical admit looks like from your school?
If you are admitted it may not be affordable. Have your run the NPC? Villanova doesn’t meet full need (yet)…so the cost can be really high. FWIW their strategic plan has them on target to meet full need in 2030, but that won’t help you now.