Do you have a specific area of interest ? Different schools excel in different environmental areas ?
Any cost constraints? If so have you run NPCs?
Bring from NY, why Rutgers ?
Admission wise, your matches are all safeties in my opinion.
The reaches are possible but reaches - sue to FGLI.
Want to check budget. Rutgers, for example, may not be appropriate but an FSU, strong in ES with its renowned atmospheric sciences program, costs less, etc. it seems like you want to be NE but then you have Northwestern.
I agree with ESF. It’s like getting Syracuse (a little) at a great rate.
You’re a very solid student. You can take the SAT again but I wouldn’t overdo it. Maybe once more.