I would move Pitzer down to Match and Haverford, Michigan, and Michigan up to reach.
American - you’d be surprised - it is a safety - but they are huge Demonstrated Interest. You see 34 ACTs rejected as they didn’t show interest and 26s getting in.
If you don’t have a definite school you want to attend, then you should not ED. Only ED if you have a clear top choice and you can clearly afford it. Use their Net Price Calculator to see.
You didn’t mention cost concerns - but you’d get some big $ at some really great schools if you wanted to keep tuition down.