Congrats on your achievements.
First off, great to have the Rutgers acceptance…is Rutgers affordable?
These statements don’t mesh…what can your family pay for college, per year? Do you qualify for a Pell Grant? Have you run the net price calculators at each of these schools to get cost estimates?
I can’t chance you, but NEU, NYU, BU, Williams are reaches, not matches. All have sub 20% accpetance rates, so are a reach for all unhooked applicants.
Have you demonstrated interest at American? If not, you should engage as much as you can with them…do virtual admissions sessions/tours/panels, reach out to your AO with a question that can’t be answered online, open emails then send you and click on links.
Is this your full list of applications?