You should be able to get school profile and college outcome for the 2022 class to see if 95% go to T50. Going to an academic rigorous school can warp your ideas about what is a good school when you compare with other classmates. Look for fit, finance, future, and fun that works for you.
I don’t understand the athletics part. Are you applying to schools believing that you are recruited athlete when it appears that you have no formal support? I would create another baseline of schools without an athletic hook, just in case that does not work out. Good luck.