You did see the part about the negative pre-read at Bowdoin, correct?
The only way that OP has ‘a very likely’ chance of admission at Hamilton, a school that is a reach for all with an 18% acceptance rate, is as a recruited athlete with full coach support. OP has to find out if that full coach support would extend to ED2 or RD. Typically the quid is for EDI, but this year there may be more flexibility. Only the coach knows.