Duke is a reach… I put it on the list just because it’s in the south. I would not add another reach, but if the NPC shows a better cost than say, Vanderbilt, it’s an option.
@doorrealthe that is false. The student needs affordable safeties and matches.
U Pitt and Rochester are two good schools to add, although not in the south.
@ProfessorMom1 your description works for private schools, but you have to be careful with OOS flagships. For them, there are really two pools, in and out of state applicants. What we normally see for score distributions is the combined result. We know that for the top state flagships, the acceptance rate of OOS is much lower. For example, in 2016, UM was 42% vs 24% . Texas has a 70 point SAT spread for the top 75 percentile between in state auto admits and OOS (1370 vs 1440).
@suzy100 Actually it’s not. Several commenters have said “are you willing to pay.” You have no idea how much he will be paying! There wasn’t even an income bracket provided. Those types of comments defer people from actually applying to schools. Comments that don’t take into account of anything and look at a sticker price. If UVA and UNC have competitive applicants, that doesn’t make them reaches. He’s equally as competitive. His test scores are 75th percentile and his GPA is great.
UNC has an 18% legal cap on OOS students. UVAs legal caps are a little higher. Both schools receive thousands of applications from competitive OOS students.
@twogirls They absolutely do, but he’s very competitive as an applicant. Just because there’s equally as qualified applicants doesn’t mean it’s a reach, it means he’s competing with similar students. Sounds like a match to me.
He is competitive yes… but these schools are not a match. You are confusing the two. A match or safety on paper does not mean an admissions match.
UNC, by law, can’t have an OOS freshmen class that is greater than 18%. UVA is a little higher. During a typical application cycle you can have 25,000 OOS applicants, and 10,000 instate applicants (UNC).
This does not mean that the student won’t get in… he is academically qualified and might… it really depends on the rest of his application …and whether he presents as being a good fit- essays etc do matter.