If colleges are looking at your application holistically, they will see that you want to do creative writing/english and appreciate you got a perfect score on English and Reading. I hope that this the case, because your extracurriculars are spot on and are GPA is good (especially the rough patch you went through). I think you stand a great chance at Smith and Oberlin (Smith in particular). Colgate, Kenyon and NYU not as much, but you definitely have a good shot. I know very little about Pitzer, Hamilton, and Grinell, so I can’t give an accurate assessment. Vassar and Carleton are very selective schools, but I think the fact you are applying to Vassar ED will help a lot. Carleton is a toss up-- it will be a reach. Hope this helps, and good luck!