Now that this is over, this is how it panned out:
Oberlin: Accepted w/ merit money
Grinnell: Accepted
Pitzer: Accepted
NYU: Accepted
Hamilton: Waitlisted
Colgate: Waitlisted
Carleton: Waitlisted
Scripps: Waitlisted (last minute add-on)
Kenyon: Waitlisted
Smith: Waitlisted
Vassar: Rejected in EDII round
Again, I was rejected from Wes in EDI and accepted to Bard and Emerson EA. Right now, I’m deciding mostly between Oberlin and Pitzer, though I’m going to the Grinnell admitted students day, so that may change my mind. Moral of the story: borderline students get waitlisted. If anyone has any questions, feel free to message me.