Your ACT math score, though totally fine for most schools, literally creates an experiment in admissions for you at some of your more selective choices. Hamilton, for example, most recently accepted only 6% of students with an SAT math score equivalent (500-600) in your range. You are getting in somewhere, but your profile makes it particularly difficult to predict where. Kenyon, Pitzer, NYU, Smith and Oberlin may be your most likely admissions. However, you may be just as likely to get into a couple of your other choices and miss one or two from this group. Good luck.