If you are from New England, when why Arizona for a safety? Why not U.Mass Amherst and/or UVM (or McGill if your grades are high enough for it to actually be a safety)?
“in or near a city” is of course not a description of U.Mass. However, it does describe UVM and McGill.
You do have a lot of reaches on your list. I think that reaches might be easier to find because they are famous. However, you should think hard about which of these reaches are a better fit for you.
With a 19% admissions rate, I do not think that I would call Wellesley College a match. Perhaps a “low reach” might be more accurate. With a 24% admissions rate I would not call Scripps a safety.