Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>cherryhillmom2 - We also are still mulling over the senior year course schedule. DS has to register on Tuesday, the 22nd and once he inputs it into the online system, he cannot change it without losing his place in line. There are around 775 kids in the senior class and only 125 spots for each of the “choice electives” so he needs to be certain and hit submit right at the start of registration. Last year a friend of his made an error and went back a few hours later to resubmit and then lost his spot in AP Psychology…once a class is full, the system locks everyone else out!!! My son wants a spot in the (much coveted) Honors Astronomy class so he must have all his ducks in a row right at the start. </p>

<p>He and I are arguing now about courseload, but our situation is reversed from yours. My son wants to take 5 or 6 AP’s (in addition to the honors Astronomy class) and I am adamant that he needs to chill a bit. This past year he took 5 AP’s, the hardest ones at our school, and his GPA has suffered for it. He says that he dosen’t care, he wants to learn what he wants to learn (but I know that is not true, he just likes to push the envelope and sometimes, my buttons). </p>

<p>He just got his January SAT scores and refuses to take the ACT. He needs to go up about 200 points to get into the tier of schools that he would like (Emory, Vanderbilt, CMU) but he will have many other options, as talked about on this thread, if he dosen’t go up. He is going to actually do some prep this time for the June test (he took the January test cold). BTW, he did go up about 50 points in CR from the PSAT to the SAT. This is with no prep, so I think that with prep, improvement is possible, for all our children!</p>

<p>I could definitely see him rushing one of the Jewish frats when he gets to college. My daughter felt that her little bro would fit right in with the AEpi’s at UF.</p>

<p>RVM: Thanks for the laugh about your dream. I can’t wait to hear about the dreams you’ll have next year waiting for results.</p>

<p>momjr - I know - I need to relax but this is just how I am. I just picked up S2 - didn’t get much more out of him than it was “fine” and I then made a wrong turn as I was taking him out to eat with his friends - 5 minutes from our house! </p>

<p>seiclan - wow! And I thought our hs was big with 650 in the class. That on-line registration system is interesting - sounds very collegiate.</p>

<p>Hope all the kids did well today on the ACT! How long does it take to get the scores back?</p>

<p>Seiclan - If you can talk your son into preparing for the SAT, I think he can increase his score. D took the SAT in October. Had high reading and writing scores. Math was bad. She had 6 tutoring sessions and her math score went up 110 points! Very good math score now. She didn’t do any prep for CR or WR and those scores remained the same. She wants to take it one more time and do some prep work for each section. First she is going to give the ACT a try in April and then June will be the final SAT. Then we are done! Her SAT score is great for all of her match and safety schools. It’s in the range for her reach schools (low end of the range). But kids from our HS have gotten in with her scores, of course plenty have been rejected with higher scores, but it’s not all about the scores.</p>

<p>I also think you should talk him out of so many ap classes for senior year. Come spring when acceptances are in and all of his friends are starting to kick back, does he want to be studying for 5 or 6 AP’s? Just sounds like a pretty tough way to end high school.</p>

1 Like

<p>I know this is a very fast moving thread, but I asked a question back on post #5703…can anyone help me out? :)</p>

<p>How many of your kids took SAT’s or ACT’s in the Fall of Senior year? How many of you found it helpful to have them study for this during the summer before? As I stated earlier, my S1 took his SAT’s just one time, in March of his junior year. That’s it. He did take an SAT prep class starting @Thanksgiving and went to March, ending the week before the exam.</p>

<p>How many times have your kids taken the SAT and/or the ACT? Improvement each time? thanks-</p>

<p>My DD took the ACT for the second time in early Sept of senior year. Same composite as first try. She took SAT twice junior year. We ended up sending both ACT scores so they could see all her best scores. She did not put in time over the summer so there was no upswing like I had hoped. </p>

<p>Sent from my ADR6300 using CC App</p>

<p>Neither of my daughters took the October SAT of senior year. Both took it for the third and last time in May of Junior year and both had their best scores then. Both went up 60 points in M/CR, 100 points total between October and May. Both had SAT prep somewhere between February and the May test. </p>

<p>DS just took the SAT in January for the first time with no prep. He is going to have private prep late March late May and he will take the June test for the second and hopefully final time. Different kid, different path, hoping he goes up more than 100 points.</p>

<p>Thanks Linymom & Seiclan…so your children were all finished in their junior year?</p>

<p>I’d love to hear from others whose kids took them in both junior and senior years…was there enough of a difference? I think having all testing done by end of junior year is ideal, but I’m wondering if those few months in-between the Spring of junior year and Fall of senior year really makes enough of a difference…I suppose we’ll just have to wait & see.</p>

<p>With so much testing going on in the junior year, maybe it’s better to keep the ball rolling and finish up then…</p>

<p>mdmom - ACT scores take about 2 weeks - the scores from today should be on-line on 2/28.</p>

<p>chocchip - I am generally not a fan of doing more ACT or SAT testing in the fall of senior year for several reasons. First - it’s hard to finalize your list of colleges to apply to if you are still trying to increase your score. I personally would rather work with test scores done during junior year - make the list - and move forward. I also feel the summer between junior and senior year is better used for an experience to add to the resume - like an internship or summer job - and starting applications/writing essays. Trying to fit test prep in there as well - does not appeal to me.</p>

<p>The other issue I see is kids holding off on submitting EA or rolling apps because they want to improve their scores - so they plan to test in the fall of senior year and apply RD instead. I guess if their scores go up dramatically it could be a good call - but so much of the time they don’t. With rolling schools - earlier is generally better. I frequently see the best test scores the second time someone tests. There are kids who take it 4-5 times - some do better each time - if they started fairly low to begin with. Many get pretty much the same score every time. And some actually go down - maybe due to the pressure they are putting on themselves.</p>

<p>So - there is no rhyme or reason to it. For our family - S1 took the SAT and ACT once each during junior year - and that was it. S2 has now taken the ACT twice during junior year - and that’s it. I’m not even tempted to have him test again in the fall.</p>

1 Like

<p>Thanks for your answer too, RVM. I can’t imagine being one of those households where my child takes the test 4 or 5 times.</p>

<p>I pretty much have my answer then and will try to follow the same path we did before. Thanks!</p>

<p>chocchipcookie, ShawD took the ACTs once and only once this fall and then applied to colleges. She had taken the PSATs twice but didn’t take the SATs. She could have improved in a second pass on the ACTs but got into the two schools to which she applied, so the only effect might be on merit scholarships.</p>

<p>ShawSon took the SATs and ACTs once each in the fall of his gap year. He had health problems in his senior year. He was prepared to take one or both of them again, but completely nailed both so he stopped.</p>

<p>In both cases, we did the xiggi method. Lots of practice tests. Going over the results to understand the errors. Half a day of SAT and ACT test each for ShawSon and a few short sessions on the math/science parts for ShawD. In both cases, the help was one-on-one rather than in a class, but very limited periods.</p>

<p>My S is taking the SAT in March for the 2nd time as a junior. We intend this to be the last time. I think there is enough pressure during the app process to have to take another test. He has worked with a tutor privately these past couple of months, mostly because he won’t work with us. it is enough to go through the screaming battles with homework, to add the SAT with it is too much to handle. just wait until he calls from college asking for help!!!</p>

<p>Also like Seiclan my son wants to take his hardest classes and too many his senior year. I am trying to talk him out of it, but he insists. He is very interested. I am proud of him and in the end let him sign up for them. I just think he is finally hitting his stride and that will bode well for his first year of college.</p>

<p>well let’s hope that all the kids who took the ACT today did well.</p>

<p>Thanks, too, for your input Shawbridge & Samtalya.</p>

<p>Actually the prep class worked very well for S1, but S2 has different strengths & weaknesses so maybe one-on-one will work better for him, don’t know yet. I’m having trouble motivating him just as a freshman, lol! :)</p>

<p>I do remember our h.s. gc suggesting for our S not to take SAT’s before March, so that’s why we signed up for March exam. We’ll play it by ear the second time around.</p>

<p>Samtalya: My S1 senior is also taking a full load, but he’s that type of kid. Every child is different & unique! :cool: Who knows, maybe my S2 will do better on the ACT…I’ll make sure he trys both options!</p>

<p>Thanks for sharing everyone’s individual situations…</p>

<p>Has anyone heard of anything about Union College in NY? Positive or negative…any info. would be great! </p>

<p>RVM: when you have a chance, can you do the naviance on Union College? Hillel info? Thanks! :)</p>

<p>Choc: my DD has a friend (njb) who goes there. I am planning to visit with DS in March as it is only half hour from RPI. I will report back. </p>

<p>Sent from my ADR6300 using CC App</p>

<p>The Hillel has a Facebook page - but I can’t post the link for some reason.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.union.edu/offices/religious-spiritual/groups/hillel/[/url]”>http://www.union.edu/offices/religious-spiritual/groups/hillel/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Small liberal arts college - about 2133 undergraduates. National Hillel website shows they have 350 Jewish undergrads - that’s quite a bit for such a small school. Our hs has only had 5 students apply in the past few years - so not much data. Union College itself reports an average unweighted GPA of 3.5 and 1290/1600 for the SAT. They are test optional, however - with an interview strongly recommended. About 39% of the freshman class applied ED. They have ED and ED II. </p>

<p>I actually have a good friend who attended a while back - she transferred to Cornell after one year - thought Union was too small. I do not know anyone there currently. Not a big draw from our area.</p>

<p>ChOCCHIP- My S1 actually did take a third SAT fall of senior year and it worked out well. After taking it March and May of Junior year (and subject tests in June) he really wanted to bring up his CR score for his ED school - which was a very selective university. </p>

<p>His theory: He figured it was a win-win situation with super-scoring. If he stayed the same - nothing lost; if he brought up his score - he felt he may have a better chance at his dream school. In the end - his score increased another 40 points.</p>

<p>I think if your child is already “in-range” for their selected schools and are only hoping to better their chances, it can’t hurt to give it a shot. I think S1 just wanted to feel that he really gave it his best effort.</p>

<p>Union looked intriguing, because like Trinity College in Hartford, they are a small LAC that has a full Engineering Dept. too.</p>

<p>Yes, Linymom, I’d love to hear feedback from you re: Union and RPI, thanks!</p>

<p>RVM: Thanks for the info. Wow, your friend transferred from Union to Cornell? We toured the Cornell campus, that’s huge! I just have a feeling my S2 may be better off in a smaller school for reasons we have all talked about.</p>

<p>dwhite: I’m kinda hoping S2 will not have a certain dream school. We have a long way to go before we go looking at colleges, but I’m hoping, like rvm’s situation, that we have a list of 4-6 possibilities where S2 would be happy at any of them, considering FA, of course!</p>

<p>Interesting re: Union Hillel…that is a great percentage for the small number of students! Also, it looks like it’s a school more for a B/B+ student…I’m intrigued!</p>

<p>Because of my obsessive nature (and love for planning), we were all set with DD’s list for college apps by the end of junior year. Her two SATs were about the same and so were her two ACTs. It felt great. I’m hoping to be in the same position with DS. I actually got him to look at the Purdue website tonight where they explain all the different kinds of engineering so I have an idea what he is looking for. He zeroed right in on his interest. While that can change, it certainly helps giving direction as some schools only have a few kinds of engineering.</p>

<p>If all goes according to plan, we will be at Union on a Friday but I have told DS that he can see a camp friend in the area if he is available that night. If that doesn’t work out, perhaps we will check out the Hillel for Shabbat.</p>

<p>CCC, my D took the SAT March of her junior year and October of her senior year. She raised her superscore by 60 points and achieved the goal she set for herself so she was happy. She studied one on one with a tutor for the first one and on her own for the second.</p>

<p>Want to second Puget Sound in Washington state. My D has applied there–great school!</p>