<p>Thank you Levi for writing this. I have contributed to my federation and thus Birthright for years, and if a deposit card gives a little hassle who cares? I have also led 18 trips to Israel for Jewish adults that are very costly. I have had joint events with the Birthright kids. Students are given basically a 10 day trip to Israel. There is nothing like this opportunity for this group of students. It is really exciting when 10-20 buses of students pull up and float in the Dead Sea or walk down the steps to the wall on Friday. A trip like this during the times they go would easily cost over $4,000 unless you stay with family. There is no better way to educate the next generation about Israel and for them to gain information they can take back to campus and beyond.</p>
<p>The Birthright kids travel with soldiers from the army and are not taken to areas in the territories. Back when the last war in Lebanon broke out. (I was on the border then) All the tours were detoured and spent extra time exploring the south, which is rarely covered on tours, except for Eilat. The security on these tours is taken most seriously.</p>
<p>As for cell phones, your best best is if you have a phone that can be unlocked, (t-mobile and AT & T) is to buy a sim card when you are there. (but may not have time upon landing) You can then receive calls for free and local calls are cheap. If you don’t have an unlocked phone, you can pick up a motorola cheap one for around $30 and then get the sim card while there. you can even order the sim card on line if you want the number before. There are many options, however not free and not the best reception at all times.</p>
<p>QM: let us know how she is doing…especially since there may be some “lurkers” who are looking at the same school…</p>
<p>re: Birthright: My older daughter went last May; she said it was life-changing…we, as parents, who managed to move to a town in NJ where her graduating class happened to have the least % of Jewish kids in decades, were so thrilled that she even wanted to go, we would have paid the full price (samtalya’s $4,000 estimate) out of college funds…not really, but you get the drift…</p>
<p>we found the process to be clear; payoneer explanation was explicit; we knew our deposit would be credited to that card received after they return…and we will give a small contribution every year to support this program…</p>
<p>Younger daughter is already planning on applying for the program through Elon Hillel…</p>
<p>Samtalya, I have a question about what you wrote:
As for cell phones, your best best is if you have a phone that can be unlocked, (t-mobile and AT & T) is to buy a sim card when you are there. (but may not have time upon landing) You can then receive calls for free and local calls are cheap. If you don’t have an unlocked phone, you can pick up a motorola cheap one for around $30 and then get the sim card while there. you can even order the sim card on line if you want the number before. There are many options, however not free and not the best reception at all times. </p>
<p>My 2 older kids went to Israel the summer after confirmation (10th grade) so they’re not eligible for birth right but what an amazing program. We had the same challenges with Payoneer for D1 but, by D2, they really had improved the system–you just have to be diligent about using it up when the kids get home (if there’s anything left on it) before the fees and deductions kick in.</p>
<p>Anyway, we were challenged by the phone option each time and I have a third daughter so my questions are, first, does “unlocked” mean a phone that an be used internationally? (I’ve had an ATT phone and the company itself had to do something to enable the international use–I assume that’s what you mean?). Once you buy the sim card, why can you receive calls for free? I guess what I don’t understand is what’s different about the Israeli (?) sim card from the sim card you’d have at home? Thanks.</p>
<p>As for sim cards, you ask AT&T to unlock your child’s phone, which will mean that it can accept sim cards from any carrier (all sim cards are the same). Then you can buy an Israeli card before they leave or they can buy one there. Depending on the phone they have, and whether they want data/internet/BBM capability, you will have to be sure that the card or plan allows that. Local calls and data will be cheap, but of course since it’s an Israeli plan, calls home to the US will be expensive depending on the rate. You can also get an international plan from AT&T but I’ve never found them to save much and data is still expensive.</p>
<p>The Chabad rabbi at UD told my DD she can go on Birthright if she gets 10 others to sign up! (She went with NFTY in 08.) Anyway, DS is going on the NFTY trip this summer. We have Verizon - not sure he can get international - but the Israel phone worked great for DD (would have been even better if she just called me, not her friends, which was against OUR rules). Payoneer was easy too; but if it’s even easier now, that’s great. DS will be in Prague, Krakow and Warsaw before Israel… I would love him to have a phone that worked from there. They don’t get the Israel phone until they actually land in Tel Aviv.</p>
<p>RVM: Thanks for being vigiliant against the prejudice that still exists. I haven’t been surfing on here as much lately with the craziness of work and DS’ sports season. And now I have to figure out our Passover menu on top of that!</p>
<p>btw, the kids are literally going for 10 days…if their cell phones allow global coverage, just put it on for 10 days and resort to messenging…we didn’t actually “talk” to our daughter for the 10 days, but she bbm’ed every day…</p>
<p>collage, only at & t and t-mobile have sim cards. these cards are used with your plan here. you need to ask company to unlock phone and allow international calling. if you have a blackberry you can add an intl data plan which is 19.99 a month so you can get email and facebook. texts are .20. you could possibly get a pay as you go phone at t-mobile for $30. your sim card here is based on your cell plan with your carrier. you can get sim cards in any country that you go to or get them on line and have them sent here. sim cards are sold in the airports and most convenience stores. this allows for cheap local calls, but dialing back to states is around .32, which is cheaper than an international plan. (around 1.50-2.25) incoming calls on all the sim cards i have used while traveling are free. so i would call home to DH and say call me back. then he uses a .2 call plan to call back.</p>
<p>verizon blackberry i am told has access to skype, which would mean free calls. </p>
<p>Liny, if you have verizon, you might want to get a blackberry so he can use skype and turn on the data plan for just the month. was in prague this past summer. such a wonderful city. i picked up a 30 t-mobile motorola phone there and got a sim card. i can now use that phone for this summer’s euro jaunt. now since your ds is going to a few countries and won’t have time to get a sim card in each location you can search the web and there are sim cards that cover several countries. cost more to make outgoing, but again incoming is free. i think they are from estonia.</p>
<p>Word to the wise about unlocking cell phones:
I would be surprised if AT&T or any other company would unlock a phone upon request. When they sell you a phone, they have already locked the phone so that it can only be used with that company. If you find a code to unlock the phone and you do this, it invalidates the warranty, and you can almost guarantee that the phone will die quickly. Furthermore, if you request this of AT&T, they will probably just put you on their international plan, which still has very expensive international calls. This is not the same as unlocking the phone.
It is far cheaper and easier to either rent a phone through a company such as Travel Cell or a similar company (we had the most luck with reception with Travel Cell over others; make sure to compare student plans with short term plans), or buy a cheap prepaid phone once in Israel, or rent one at Ben Gurion Airport. Israel is the cell phone capitol of the world; there is no shortage of opportunities to get cell phones there. Nevertheless, I made sure that my kids had phones before they went - because it was the only way for me to make sure that they had one (a couple of them have, in the past, told me they would get cell phones when traveling internationally, and then have not done it!)</p>
<p>levi, you are right, travel cell is a good company and getting a phone in ben gurion is ok too if the trip allows you to stop. travel cell will send the phone to you before you leave.</p>
<p>i don’t have at & t so i don’t know how they treat unlocking, but t-mobile is great with it. u just request and they send you the unlock code. never has there been a problem with warranties, plans don’t change to international unless you add an intl data plan which i do on my phone, but not on my daughters when we travel. etc. I have done this with at least 7 phones aver the last 8 years of spending the summers overseas. </p>
<p>Now with these two companies merging, if a t & t doesn’t allow it, i will be more careful with my requests.</p>
<p>mhc: DS is going on NFTY L’Dor V’Dor (like his sister did).</p>
<p>RE: Phones. H is the expert on this here. Will leave all this to him. All I know is that DS has been putting up with an old LG NV (or something like that) until iPhone came to Verizon. He’s got a b-day coming up and that’s all he wants! Thanks for all the suggestions, though! Maybe he can find a connection somewhere, somehow and contact us while he’s in Eastern Europe.</p>
<p>I’m with you Queen’s Mom! Love discussing food!</p>
<p>I do not like Borscht, but love Gazpacho! (I know, not related, oh well)</p>
<p>This talk about cell phones is making my head spin. The kids that go to Israel as teenagers say it IS life changing and so we try to give them these opportunities to broaden their horizons and in turn, come back and get involved. I went to Israel in college with the now defunct AZYF (American Zionist Youth Foundation) and spent 3 months touring and working on a Kibbutz.</p>
<p>As we all know, this type of experience multiplies itself in so many positive ways.</p>
<p>My daughter’s Birthright trip organizer is Young Judea, and they are offering the option to rent an israeli cell phone for free. Local and incoming calls are free and outgoing overseas calls are 39 cents/minute. My daughter has an AT and T Blackberry so we might get an international plan for that instead.</p>
<p>I went to Israel the summer in between HS and college with BBYO. It was a wonderful experience. I’d love to go back.</p>
<p>Levirm, if you’ve had an account with ATT for a while, they will give you no problem with unlocking the phone. I’ve done it twice so that my kids could use sim cards purchased overseas.</p>
<p>As I mentioned, my daughters’ Jewish Day school takes seniors to Israel for 3 week trips before graduation. They use Israelphones which offers lots of differernt plan options, free incoming calls and text messages, Blackberry rentals. You can get a local US number to call which will ring on the phone in Israel for a $10 initial fee and then 15 cents a minute or you can have one designated home number that the kids can call home to for 13 cents a minute If you have an unlocked phone you can get an inexpensive sim card. There’s just a lot of options.</p>
<p>That is good to know mhc! I hadn’t asked AT&T about unlocking in a while - last time I asked I was treated like I was from another planet! Their rationale (which I understand, actually) was that I bought the phone from them at a huge discount with the understanding that I would only be using the phone under my AT&T contract, and that they do have an international plan (expensive!) And, they pointed out, I have a discount through my employer, AND an old plan that they don’t even sell anymore…I just couldn’t argue with any of this. But - I’ll try again next time so thanks!</p>
<p>levirm, I have my own and three kids phones on the account, which I’ve had for some time, so the facts of your employer’s account, discount and now discontinued plan might alter the equation. But once ATT understood that my children would be going abroad and returning, so that I wasn’t taking their phone permanently to another carrier, they had no problem. And for that matter, I was still be paying the monthly bill on the unlocked phone while the kid was away.</p>
<p>I’ve found that buying a local, pay as you go sim card and popping it into their familiar Blackberry is the best approach. Plus, they always have the option of popping their old US ATT card back in to use with an International Plan.</p>