Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Thanks for the general congrats, socaldad. </p>

<p>I’ll say from following B-student threads for the past couple of years that every year 3.Xers have done excellently in college admissions. Not only have they been surprisingly successful at quite selective schools, they also have had outstanding success in being admitted to schools they love and that fit them. Merit money has also been very generous to these kids, usually more than parents ever expected.</p>

<p>It’s a tricky passage, and I won’t say parents shouldn’t ever worry about these kids - they’re in a tough spot competitively, and it takes care to build a good list, usually more research and more visiting, than for a straight A or barely B student. </p>

<p>Many 3.X students also manage some late-game academic successes that pull them up a notch between mid-junior and mid-senior year. Late blooming is common for these kids, since so many of them dragged their GPA in 9th or 10th grade simply because of not being mature enough. Many of these kids are lopsided, and it’s often later in junior/early senior year that their strengths really start to stand out. Colleges care about this more than we usually give them credit for.</p>

<p>We vets will still be there for those coming up - we all want to know how the story ends!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>To be fair, a number of the graduating seniors are the A-student older siblings of B-students, if I’m not mistaken. A number of parents on this thread were going through the search with one child (or, like Rockvillemom, had just been through it), but keeping an eye on the future for a younger child at the same time. </p>

<p>I think when you see what it takes to get into the “usual suspects,” and you have another kid coming along who might not have those credentials, you start thinking, “Oy! Where do the B students go?”</p>

<p>When we started our search process, I was dismayed to see that just about every school I’d considered for my kid claimed that 90+% of their students were ranked in the top decile of their high school graduating class. I could not, for the life of me, figure out where the second decile goes.</p>

<p>No, This thread was started in May of last year but I think many of the B students were high B students and some ended up doing very well on the SAT’s/ACT’s. Also, if you look at these colleges, you’ll see that I think all of them are private colleges that look at the applications holistically. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>socaldad, I think I joined this before the end of ShawD’s junior year, but her grades were UW GPA 3 freshman year (actually 2.98) and 3.1 sophomore year. I could see improvement but she went to 3.6 junior year and stayed about there during the first semester senior year (I hope senioritis doesn’t lead to a big decline). So, I’d say she was a solid B student moving up to a high B/low A student over the course of her HS career – so definitely a B to B+ average over HS. Her school is a pretty competitive in the sense that the students are strong (and they had a killer season this year with Ivies), so some schools might have given her credit for being in a school with tough competition.</p>

<p>I started on this thread with DD - a definite B student (despite WGPA of 3.6). Very avg ACT/SAT. With her GPA, she would have been able to aim higher with a great SAT or ACT, but being a terrible test-taker, that didn’t happen. Perhaps she could have aimed higher at some privates, but her GC really sold her short to me – made us feel that she’d be lucky to get in anywhere and I didn’t know enough at that point to look elsewhere. Come to think of it, I asked the GC multiple times: “what other schools should we consider?” I wish I had a quarter for every time she suggested Loyola in MD (despite DD’s first requirement that there be a substantial number of Jews at college).</p>

<p>Anyway, DD found her academic fit at University of Delaware (still a great school) and is really rising to the ocassion academically now that she’s there. </p>

<p>I still hang around here because I like the exchange with like-minded people. My DS is an A student who is a very good test taker, but I still feel that I can gain a lot from all of you here.</p>

<p>Congrats to all of your D/S who have found their fit and will be attending fabulous schools. The “best” school is really the “best fit” school.</p>

<p>Here’s my perspective. I went through the process with S1 - very, very high stat in every regard - grades, test scores, rank, EC’s, etc. He did not get into his first choice ED school - although he did have good options by the end of March - the winter waiting was tough. Very tough.</p>

<p>So - with S2 - who has a B+ average, decent test scores and an average class rank - it is hard to feel calm. I don’t think I am selling him short and I don’t think the issue is that I have little faith in him. It’s just the horror stories you read about and hear about where a decent kid gets denied or waitlisted everywhere (I swear the Washington Post does one of these pretty much every year) or the kid who gets denied everywhere except for the one safety school they really don’t want to go to make me nervous.</p>

<p>All I want is for S2 to have a smooth process - where he either is accepted to his first choice school ED or applies to a number of schools and has a few options to choose from. Either of those outcomes would mean success. I also feel I have to pay a lot of attention to fit - academic fit in particular. I think after conversations with many parents of “B” students - that S2 will do best at a school where he is in the top half of the class. I don’t see him flourishing at a reach school. He is a slower reader and I think the workload would kill him. So - considerations such as that make it a little more complicated as well.</p>

<p>Could I be overthinking and over analyzing the situation? Yup. But a good outcome will mean it was all worthwhile.</p>

<p>I think that some of us gravitated to this list because we have very high achieving 1st kids and saw our more laid back second kids as “B” students. When I first discovered this thread last spring, my daughter had a strong GPA, but was not taking any AP courses and had a first SAT score that was in the mid 1800’s. She ended up with a much higher ACT score, and took 3 AP courses as a senior, so I would consider her more of an “A-” student. She would not have had a chance at the most selective schools that have large Jewish poplulations, so this thread was helpful in identifying realisitic choices. </p>

<p>I agree with Emmybet that strong B, B+ and A- students have had a lot of success in college admissions this year. It seems like the most selective schools have gotten more competitive, but that the next group of schools have not.</p>

<p>Rockvillemom - My experiences and son echo your last post. I too, am just praying for a smooth process, as I know that there will be a school for my son (though perhaps not one of his top choices…since he has higher aspirations than motivation). He was an A student for his first two years of hs but this year, with 5 of the toughest AP classes, has been averaging an even mix of A’s and B’s. We won’t know until June how this shakes out his GPA and class rank. </p>

<p>I will be on this thread quite a bit as we narrow down his college list (after seeing what he can do on the June SAT). I am quite sure of which instate schools that he will apply to, since the choices are limited here in Florida but we are very up in the air on the out of state matches and safeties (and I want him to have some choices that he will actually consider attending). We will talk.</p>

<p>Kathiep, I was happy to include you. Calv1n, sorry to miss your son. If I missed anyone else, please chime in. Here’s the updated list of our seniors: </p>

<p>calv1n’s S: UC Santa Cruz
chocchipcookie’s S: Tufts University
collage1’s D: Bucknell University
college4three’s S: Columbia University
Emilyb’s S: Bates College
Emmybet’s D: Adelphi University
Franfur’s D: Lafayette College
Holliesue’s D: Juniata College
Kathiep’s S: Champlain College
Levrim’s D: Johns Hopkins University
Mdcissp’s S: Towson University
Mhc48’s D: University of Delaware
Momjr’s D: Boston Univerity
Rodney’s D: Elon University
Shawbridge’s D: Queen’s University</p>

<p>with a child at the bottom of this thread in terms of stats, I can emphatically say that I did not sell my daughter short; she was very fortunate to be accepted to Elon and is, in fact, very fortunate that she applied ED;
her classmates and friends had a very difficult admission year…it has not been a picnic for girls in this GPA range if they applied to matches and reaches in regular decision…</p>

<p>there have been times (often) that I was concerned that this thread had really turned into a higher stat thread…</p>

<p>I do not have a child who was a late bloomer; in fact, as we speak, she is struggling to finish her senior year without imploding…she is a “B” student; she will always be a “B” student…she does not have the ability to be an “A” student…</p>

<p>Its great that alot of the kids on here “saw the light” or “finally came into their own”, but to assume that every kid can and will do that diminishes the importance of this type of thread on CC…</p>

<p>rant over…I love you all…just wanted to set the record straight</p>

<p>Hey guys,</p>

<p>I need to second DeskPotato’s observation. I came here for a few reasons, the first being that I have a child who is younger who will fit this profile. I knew that I’d find some good advice here and some haimishe folks, too. </p>

<p>With regard to my son’s admissions process, I have to say that he is, indeed, a super-high-stat, gazillion AP class, athlete, leader, etc. I think that several of the kids on the list also fit this profile.</p>

<p>But stay calm!!! I have an older D who fit the B-profile and is happily ensconced in a school which fits her perfectly. 3.x students do very, very well in admissions.</p>

<p>@calv1n: I’d send to the people who will share your joy. Whether they see it as a request for a gift is up to them. Also, I’d love a do-ever. These kids have it made!</p>

<p>I also joined this thread on a quest to try to find where do all the B students go? (sounds like material for a song). And so far the thread has far exceeded my expections. Thank you, RVM and everyone else! While we would all hope that our B students will evolve in B+/A- students, this may happen with some but not others. No matter which way the chips fall, we all wish to support our students as best we can - so that they end up finding a good fit and feel good about themselves no matter what the outcome. And for our juniors, developing a list of reasonable college possibilities seems like a key goal at this stage of the process.</p>

<p>If I may chime in, my S is an A+ student. He has the goods to get into any school. However, with those top schools, you never know. We use this thread to call attention to possible safeties or merit aid schools. There have been several schools mentioned in this thread which I had no idea had significant Jewish presence. Despite the title, this thread is useful for all students.</p>

<p>I didn’t mean to imply at all that all B students are simply on their way to becoming A students. I wanted to paint a broad spectrum of how B students finish out their application process. Some do a bit better, some stay the same, some do drop their grades as their course rigor increases. Some find they peak in ECs, special areas, sports and other interests, but others continue along a smoother path. </p>

<p>I refer to these kids as “3.X” because we have had many discussions on these kinds of threads about whether the “X” number makes a difference. We’ve even separated threads along the “.0,” “.3” or “.6” line at times. This thread has shown that we can talk about “students who get B’s” in an inclusive way, regardless of test scores, upward or downward trends, or any other factors. </p>

<p>Yes, they get into different schools, earn different kinds of merit money, and have different interests. Sometimes you can relate that to a tenth of a point in GPA, but usually there are too many other factors to figure. We can’t even begin to measure one HS alongside another - that is truly unfathomable.</p>

<p>I do think that over several years there has been a definite pattern where parents of 3.X students worry there won’t be a school that either fits or will accept their child, and every year dozens of us are very pleasantly surprised. I do think that the experiences and information shared on threads like this one are often what has made the difference for these families. I know it was incredibly helpful for mine.</p>

<p>And for the record, D is finishing her year with pretty much the grades she’s always gotten - As and Bs divided exactly between English-Social Studies and Math-Science.</p>

<p>I did not mean to cause such a stir. it was a fun way to point out how well your kids did, and how obsessed we can all be. I think you should all be proud. No need to defend. </p>

<p>I only hope that my d gets some good acceptances. I hope that your wisdom and good fortune rub off on the rest of us. I don’t think she will be a late bloomer, or have a dramatic shift in her grades. We will need some mazel.</p>

<p>socaldad, I perceived you as paying a compliment. :slight_smile: Hope you’ve gotten a chance to catch some zzzzzs after your whirlwind tour!</p>

<p>Hey everyone:</p>

<p>I can’t believe it’s been at least a week since I’ve posted…life sure is busy! :)</p>

<p>First I want to congratulate all the posters whose children have now made decisions on their college choices: Collage1 and Francfur, Kathiep, calv1n and Shawbridge! Anyone else (?) Of course I also congratulate all the seniors and parents that also have made their decisions along the way! (Rodney, Mhc, etc…)</p>

<p>Shawbridge…delighted to hear your D chose the larger, more active school with the higher Jewish population…isn’t that the one closer to your relatives? Good for her…hope it works out nicely!</p>

<p>Emmybet…Congrats on Adelphi…we have friends that live right near the school so we took our own tour and we were quite impressed! Beautiful, flat campus (totally opposite of Tufts with all those hills!) and so close to NYC! What fun your D will have! I’ve heard their theatre dept. is top notch…did you know that the creator of “Rent”, Jonathan Larson went there? Anyway, the best to her and hope she enjoys her college years there.</p>

<p>It sounds like many of us were drawn to this thread for the same reasons. Good title, RVM, and lots of good ideas, suggestions have come out of this thread. It’s always nice to hear how other parents go through the process…it certainly has given me ideas and ways to be more proactive. Also, it has helped me to step back and realize that every child is unique with their own strengths and weaknesses and ways to help each child see their full potential.</p>

<p>I feel better prepared now to do this again with S2. He is picking EC’s that are totally different than S1 and that’s what keeps it interesting! Just in his freshman year we have seen his weighted GPA go from a 3.2 to a 3.6…really awesome. More confidence from him and a mom who is trying to back away a bit…good combination. Not always easy as all of you well know!</p>

<p>I guess I’m in for the long haul too with S2 being a freshman…of course I’ve already started to compile a list of schools to check out! For now I’m concentrating on end of the school year activities for my senior and spend the time buying dorm stuff…very exciting and sad at the same time…for those of you with kids in college already I’m definitely going to need some support and a few boxes of tissues this coming Fall!</p>

<p>I never would have heard of, or as to one or two I did “hear about”, would have realistically considered suggesting my D apply to, some schools she did were it not for this thread. They were just not on the radar in my area, of her friends or even her guidance counsellor. Afterwards the school GC complemented me on the choices and aptness of schools I encouraged D to apply to.</p>

<p>Applying to and getting into those schools widened my D’s choices, expanded her view of college, made her feel much better about herself and helped her find discover and hone what she wanted. Her top two “second choice” but very much in contention schools were ones that she never would have applied to were it not for this thread.</p>

<p>I would not have followed up with additional superscoring of the ACT were it not for this thread or particularly some members of this community.</p>

<p>I would not have followed up with additional information Admissions Representatives in some cases at all, in the other cases in the same way were it not for this thread.</p>

<p>I wouldn’t have contacted or visited Hillel Directors at schools were it not for this thread.</p>

<p>My D ultimately was admitted to the school she first loved and wanted to go to before I joined this thread, but that was very late in the game and both she and I would have been basket cases by then were it not for the other alternatives we got here.</p>

<p>And now you just have to be an active alum next year and help some noobies with what you have learned! </p>

<p>I’m glad this thread has been helpful. For me - it is a fun way to commiserate and to share ideas and info in a non-competitive environment. Could not ask for anything more!</p>

<p>Ok, this is off-topic a bit (but something most may face in a few years) but I need a bunch of Jewish mommas to tell me everything will be ok so…</p>

<p>My S leaves for Israel with Birthright on Sunday (Mother’s Day!) Ever since I heard the news last night about Bin Laden, I’m worried. Very worried. I know, I know. This is a normal state for many of us. </p>

<p>My H says if there are any targets for revenge, they will be against America, not Israel and that this is no better or worse time to travel. Everything will be Okay, right?</p>