Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>I hear you, rvm. We found it very helpful attending faculty and staff presentations…</p>

<p>RVM: When I read your first posts about the two schools I thought that maybe he should just apply to both, and I see that you are leaning in that direction. I don’t know much about the U of Tampa, but I have vacationed in the area and really love it. It can’t hurt to have him apply and wait to visit until you see whether it’s a true contender.</p>

<p>A lot of kids from our HS attend Salisbury, and they all seem to love it, however I the majority are not Jewish. I still think it’s worth applying as an in-state safety.</p>

<p>It’s interesting that your HS naviance shows high acceptance rates from JMU. Our Maryland HS seems to do very well there also. I know of some kids with stats on the low end who were accepted. I think that it might be easier to get in from out of state, especially if they are familiar with the high school.</p>

<p>Cherryhill, it sounds like JMU would be a good option for your son also.</p>

<p>RVM, JMU must like your school do the rigorous academics and high standings. there must be good success from the students once in jmu. i am sure that is what you are seeing when you see the stats from naviance. so you have an S with great scores from a rigorous outstanding high school. what more could a college want? (ps. except to maybe to hire the mom in admissions or pr!)</p>

<p>Hi Cherryhillmom:</p>

<p>If your S wants rah, rah experience and UCONN is on your list he will probably love it. They are very big into the whole rah, rah scene and the girl that we know that goes there (Jewish) absolutely LOVES it.</p>

<p>We also know someone at Bentley who would like to have more rah, rah at the school but doesn’t. It is more academic oriented.</p>

<p>Hope everyone enjoyed their day! I got some wonderful attention from my boys! (I’ll treasure it, with boys it doesn’t happen very often! ;))</p>

<p>I posted a little Mother’s Day treat on the Modern Jewish History book club thread:
<a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parent-cafe/1092936-modern-jewish-history-book-group-6.html?highlight=jewish+book+club[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parent-cafe/1092936-modern-jewish-history-book-group-6.html?highlight=jewish+book+club&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>RVM: I suggest that your son apply to his top choices very early, particularly apply to Towson early. Do not apply ED because this can hurt scholarship chances. If your son gets into Towson early, then it is completely unnecessary to apply to extra safeties. I think Salisbury and Tampa are not the right choices for what you are looking for. Jewish life at Salisbury appears to be barely existent. If you want a Florida school, then apply to U. of Florida at Gainsville and University of Miami. I do not think you need to worry with a 30 ACT and nice extra-curriculars.</p>

1 Like

<p>Thanks for the link levirm. mdcissp - I assure you his app to Towson will be going out in August! I just want to be sure he has options besides Towson, however. He vetoed Salisbury - but was interested in Tampa - so I do think he will be applying there as a safety school. While it requires a plane ride - many other components of it fit what we are looking for. If it were closer - we’d be visiting - but as it stands - we will just see what happens next fall.</p>

<p>RVM: Based on our experience with S1’s safety, that being that the closer to decision time we got the less he liked it, having more than one safety is a great plan…During junior year the safety school seemed like a strong option. Alot can happen in the mind of a teenager in a year.</p>

<p>I definitely agree with 2-3 safeties … but I’ll chime in that he shouldn’t apply anywhere he knows he doesn’t want to go. Having “a few more just so there’s a choice” is tricky - it can be overwhelming at the end stage of the process. In the long run, we had a couple where it was just wasted app money and extra stress come decision time (those schools always seem to be the ones that deluge you with mail). Although of course some kids realize at the end that the “mom’s picks” really look pretty good. So I guess it’s a gut decision.</p>

<p>I’d just say that too many that are more or less the same, especially if they are safeties, are overkill, and maybe have more of a negative effect than you think.</p>

<p>EmmyBet - congrats on Brandeis - has the decision been made?</p>

<p>I’m thinking he will have 3 safeties - Towson, Tampa and JMU. Maybe 6-7 schools total. He doesn’t want to discuss it further until late June - so I’ll just twist in the wind until then! Kidding. Sort of.</p>

<p>It has been a nerve racking few weeks at our house. Our daughter graduated from Michigan last weekend and our son FINALLY decided he wanted to go there next year! Whew. We were at the hotel for graduation, when he finally clicked the decision button on April 30. Nothing like waiting until the last minute. </p>

<p>He had a hard time making a decision because he could see benefits and drawbacks to each school (in fact, one night he described his perfect college which had parts from all 5 schools and located in warm New Orleans.) In the end he gave up Tulane, Emory, Wisconsin and Indiana (Kelley) for Michigan. He hopes to get into the Ross Business School next year and it was difficult to give up a pre-admit at Indiana, but he felt that Michigan had better academics, aside from business school, in case he decides he doesn’t want to go that route. His sister’s classmates were admitted to some amazing grad programs and this solidified his decision.</p>

<p>I have to say Indiana went the extra mile, and even had a VP from Goldman Sachs call our son on Saturday afternoon to encourage him to go to IU. It didn’t help that all of his sister’s friends thought he was psycho to consider going anywhere but UM. Going to Michigan on graduation weekend is like being surrounded with Wolverines on hormones. My daughter was also admitted to Rush Medical University in Chicago, so she will begin Medical school in September. Lots of changes happening this fall. </p>

<p>I want to thank all the regular posters on this thread. You have been a wonderful group throughout this process. Although this is our third and last child going through the college admissions process, I hope to keep on reading this thread so that I might be able to help someone else on this journey.</p>

1 Like

<p>Moltobene - What did you see as the negatives about Emory? That is high on my son’s list.</p>

<p>Congrats on graduation, Moltobene. Our boys will be Wolverines together next year :)</p>

<p>Actually, he liked Emory very much, but they offered him no scholarships and we were not eligible for financial aid. Interestingly, colleges will reduce their costs if you have a second child in college, but NOT if they are in graduate school. He liked the business school a great deal (ranked 3rd in the Business Week undergraduate rankings), but he felt that the campus was almost too pristine. We live in a very nice wooded suburban neighborhood and he said it felt like walking through our neighborhood and not a college campus. He didn’t get too much of a school pride feeling (no sweatshirts/t-shirts with school logos, etc.) Also, the lack of football/basketball sports held him back. Here’s a small anecdote about his visit: he spoke with a graduate student getting his MBA at Emory who had gone to Michigan undergrad. Our son said that the grad student had good things to say about the B-school, but when he spoke about Michigan his face lit up and he went on for quite some time about what a great 4 years he had there. Granted undergrad and grad school experiences are radically different, but this was a prime example of what he sees when he speaks to Michigan and Tulane grads–absolute love for their schools. He didn’t get that feeling at Emory. Lastly, we consulted with a friend in NYC that does I-Banking and he heavily suggested Ross for recruiting, although he said that Emory sends kids to the big banks, but that the kids have to get themselves to NYC, because not that many banks actually recruit on campus. Note, this was a personal opinion and may not be true in actuality.</p>

<p>So those were his impressions. The kids seemed smart and very preppy. Lots of Vineyard Vines shorts and polos, which he actually likes to wear, so that was not a put-off, but it might be for others. His sister also looked at it and had the same impressions and decided not to attend, although one of her best friends did go there and liked it.</p>

<p>It will depend on what you are looking for in academics. It has a very strong pre-med program and great teacher-student interaction, which you lose when you attend a big state university. Like I said earlier, there are no perfect places, just places that are a good fit for your kid.</p>

<p>That’s GREAT! We need to have them meet during move-in week. Last weekend, one of my daughter’s friends (from NYC) told the story about how her Dad made her meet this girl from Kansas for coffee because he had gone to Tulane with the girl’s father. She groaned and agreed to meet my daughter at Starbuck’s. They talked for two hours. Eventually, they pledged the same sorority and became best friends. So these meet-ups really work!</p>

<p>Thanks for the reply. My son is leaning toward premed and dosen’t care about school spirit. Since son is finishing up his junior year, we are starting his tentative college list. Prestige and academics are important to him. He is not willing to look at UMich or Tulane for some, most likely dumb, reason. Incidently, I’ve never heard of what Vineyard vines is…no one wears that brand at my son’s hs. Guess I will google it and find out…</p>

<p>Seiclan: LOL, Vineyard Vines is a store on the east coast that sells lots of school emblem ties and shorts with terriers on them…let your imagination run wild! If your son doesn’t care about school spirit then Emory sounds like a great match. I know one of my daughter’s friends, who she played competitive tennis with in high school, did pre-med there and was just admitted to Emory Med school and our local med school. One of my husband’s law partner’s sons loved it there and majored in physics/math/business and just got a job in Boston with a big bank. This kid was super-smart in high school, but not really very social, in fact my daughter only saw him in her AP classes. He thrived at Emory and was a dorm assistant for a couple of years.</p>

<p>My son also, very smart, not very outgoing or social (although girls like him cause he is super cute). I see Emory as a good match for him but we will see. He may do better at a “B student” college where he can be in the top percent academically.</p>

<p>We’ll try to work that out, Moltobene. Although my son is going into the engineering school, he’s thinking about applying to Ross sophmore year to do a double major (although I’m encouraging him to stick to engineering for undergrad and then maybe an MBA for grad school…the double major just seems so tough because there’s not a lot of overlap). Is he on any of the Facebook pages for Class of 2015?</p>

<p>Hi Seiclan!</p>

<p>Vineyard Vines is sort of the Male version of Talbot’s. Very bright, preppy colors in pinks, oranges, greens…those plaid shorts you see guys wear, but in the bright colors…they have ties with college emblems…preppy is definitely the word to use to describe that store.</p>

<p>UMich: I’ve heard engineering is all encompassing and that sometimes it’s hard to finish in 4 years. I may caution you against adding business to that…much more advantageous to go for an MBA if that’s what he’s interested in.</p>

<p>Moltobene:</p>

<p>Mazel Tov on college grad and now admitted to med. school, wow! :cool:</p>

<p>Seiclan: I know this an obvious question, but is your S looking at UMiami? Vanderbilt? Rice? We know a few people from up here in NE that went to Emory and were quite happy. Are still down there now, living and working in the area.</p>