Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>samtalya and others: I’m not allowed by CC rules to link a you tube video but search for Elon Dining Services; what a hoot!!!..I tried to post it in Campus Vibe but it wouldn’t let me do that either…</p>

<p>I am pretty bummed today for D1, who was wait listed AGAIN for Mayanot Birthright. This is the third time. After a phone call, they tell us to be patient, etc, but it still feels like crap to hear friends excited about going while she’s in limbo.</p>

<p>Re: Hulu and TV. Most of the kids watch TV on the computer, but the boys often have HUGE televisions for marathon video game playing.</p>

<p>BTW, congrats to emmybet’s D for choosing Adelphi!</p>

<p>levirm, I’ve no idea if it’s possible to block hulu, but it might be a losing battle. It just takes one good friend who’s a computer expert to work their way around the block, and your work is undone. Plus, there’s youtube and amazon on demand ($80 a year but still) and netflix (similar) and the network websites themselves. </p>

<p>CountingDown, your 12 hours to clean out your son’s room is stiffening my spine, and snapping my wallet shut. Less is more! Less is more! D1 is off on her senior class trip, otherwise I’d be texting it to her in great big flashing capital letters. :)</p>

<p>levirm, I think it is blocking Hulu is sort of like putting a finger in the hole in the dam. We’re decidedly anti-TV. I wanted not to have one, though ShawWife requested one when the kids were younger. But the deal was, no commercial TV except for the Super Bowl, elections, etc., but an unlimited budget for books, audiobooks, art supplies, sports supplies and educational computer games. That lasted for quite a while, but in the last few years, they were able to get anything via the legal sources described by SlitheyTove and less than legal ones. ShawWife thought both kids had been so diligent and especially ShawSon (getting better than straight A’s as a severely dyslexic kid) that she asked me to get a flat screen TV for our family room. </p>

<p>A TV won’t necessarily harm academic performance. After ShawSon’s freshman year at one of the top LAC’s in which he had gotten one A-, 6 A’s and an A+ in eight courses and won a prize for academic performance, he asked if he could have a TV because he liked to study while he was watching football games and baseball games and he was watching them on a big screen in the dorm lounge and couldn’t work. I said yes. I figured he could see whatever he wanted to anyway and given his performance, we should be cutting him a little more slack to manage his life. ShawWife said “I’m uncomfortable with that.” He said, “Mom, have I ever done anything to suggest that I won’t give the appropriate amount of effort needed to do well in school?” She said, “Well, no. OK.” He just finished the year with a TV and equally good grades. So, although I’m not a big fan of TV, a TV need not be bad for work.</p>

<p>cherryhill - here’s national Naviance for Furman:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 4538
Accepted: 3080
Percent Accepted: 67.87%
Enrolled: 656</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 30 25 27
ACT English: 33 26 29
ACT Math: 30 25 27
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 2045 1760 1902
SAT I Math: 680 600 640
SAT I Critical Reading: 690 580 635</p>

<p>I agree with above posters that this is probably not a great option for a Jewish student. What’s on the list so far?</p>

<p>Rodney - PM me the link - I googled for it and did not come up with whatever you were referencing.</p>

<p>C4Three: I’m sorry to hear that your daughter was waitlisted for birthright again. It took my daughter 4 tries to get on a trip, and then she got mono and had to cancel at the last minute. She’s finally in Israel now. She was too superstitious to post anything about it on facebook until she landed in Tel Aviv. I hope that your daughter gets pulled off the waitlist. If she doesn’t, she might want to consider applying with a different tour operator. Has she tried applying for a trip from her school? My daughter had much better luck with those trips.</p>

<p>Crossing Furman off, thanks everyone for reminding me of past posts and current viewpoints.</p>

<p>Rockville - National Naviance? Do all colleges do this?</p>

<p>S2 watched plenty of hockey and Netflix on his laptop, so having a TV might not make it any worse. (His dorm had cable in the rooms, but did not carry ESPN. Whew!) I’m more concerned about him having a single in the fall and having a TV. I want to make sure he gets out and has friends. Long-time GF broke up w/him in January and it has been a tough time.</p>

<p>Slithey, I suppose I could have taken pics of his room, but that would be a pretty scary thing! :slight_smile: He does realize that he needs to take a lot less to school in the fall. He had packed a ton of cooking equipment, but the kitchen in his dorm was gross and tiny. That stuff will be staying home until he either moves off-campus or gets a lottery number which gets him into a nicer dorm. Not all of the Tufts dorms are small and cramped. Some are veritable palaces.</p>

<p>It is a bummer to hear how many times folks get waitlisted for Birthright before getting a spot. S2 wanted to go, but he has plans for other summers that may make it difficult to apply again. FYI – Tufts has a Birthright tour, and I noticed on the Hillel site that they are looking for a new coordinator for the program on campus.</p>

<p>We know a couple of kids who did the Alexander Muss HS in Israel and had a great time.</p>

<p>cherryhill - yes - as far as I know. When you use Naviance - you see the scattergrams for your hs. But they also have an admissions tab which gives you the stats I posted. I’m guessing they just take it right from the college’s common data set - or maybe colleges fill out a form for Naviance. Let me know any other schools you want it for and I will PM to you.</p>

<p>Those waitlisted for Birthright may look for a Meor trip. They are very reasonably priced - a few hundred dollars including airfare for, typically, a three week trip. It is often possible to go with a different college’s group. Full disclosure: the students will be required to take classes in the morning - single gender - also morning minyan at least for men, and then do fun stuff in the afternoon. They WILL be allowed to wear swimsuits, go out at night, mix with the other gender, etc. They will not be required to do a “one on one” but can choose to do this if they want. The rabbis who go are usually very charismatic and appeal to this age group. Meor is connected with Chabad, so very accepting and open to any level of observance while hoping to increase observance. Most students who go on the trips are Reform. Once in a while, a student becomes so taken with the Lubavitch lifestyle that he or she embraces it, but this is highly unusual. Students who grow up with no observance whatsoever are most likely to do this.
[MEOR</a> - Visit Israel](<a href=“http://meor.org/visitisrael/overview.asp]MEOR”>http://meor.org/visitisrael/overview.asp)</p>

<p>What do we think about Clemson for a Jewish student? It looks like they have a small Hillel. I think I previously looked at it and decided to pass - but Cherryhill’s Furman question got me to rethinking what else she could substitute and I looked at Clemson. For my son - it would be a match. I also noticed that they have an unusual college combining business and psychology:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I had not previously noticed that and found it to be of interest. So - any thoughts on Jewish life at Clemson?</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 16282
Accepted: 10224
Percent Accepted: 62.79%
Enrolled: 3383</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 30 25 27
ACT English:<br>
ACT Math:<br>
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 1955 1685 1820
SAT I Math: 670 580 625
SAT I Critical Reading: 640 550 595</p>

<p>We did have some brief discussion of Clemson back in January - conclusion was too southern/conservative/Christian. I think with the exception of CofC - SC is out.</p>

<p>My S’s orthopedist has two S’s at Clemson. They’re not Jewish, so I don’t have any feedback on that aspect. I do know that the boys really like the school. Both are pre-meds. I get the impression that Clemson has a decent partying side, I guess that accompanies their great athletic program. Big school spirit.</p>

<p>One thing to keep in mind is that Clemson is public. RVM, are you able to determine whether Clemson is required to accept a certain percentage of students from in-state? This might make it a bit harder to get into than a private.</p>

<p>RVM’s son has a very good chance of being accepted to Clemson; I do know a number of mixed-marriage kids who had it on their lists as part of the group of safeties that they applied to, but the only kid I know attending next year is decidedly not Jewish, and, in fact, I don’t think this school will be a very good fit for him at all (but obviously wasn’t asked)…he has been brought up in a very sheltered Christian/white dominated household and neighborhood…and my knowledge of Clemson is that it is very diverse…especially racially…I could of course be wrong…just my impressions…</p>

<p>That program sounds VERY interesting though!! (I would have LOVED it!)</p>

<p>Clemson- Big school with only 200 jewish students. great programs, lots of spirit and partying, elevating their academics since new president came in, but if you want more of a jewish presence this would not be the place to go. kind of in the middle of nowhere.</p>

<p>we chose not to visit. like rvm said if you want a jewish presence c of c is your best best.</p>

<p>wow…missed a day or so on cc and just catching up! </p>

<p>Moltobene and Countingdown: thanks for all those great suggestions. I will definitely print out those pages when we move into dorm. We are lucky to be less than 2 hours away from the college, so we will definitely be adopting the “less is more” mantra.</p>

<p>momjr: how’s D’s trip on Birthright going? Stillnadine: your D is there too?</p>

<p>Emmybet: Is it final on your D’s college decision? Excellent choice (imo) for a theater major to be so close to NYC!</p>

<p>Never heard of Hulu in my little sheltered corner of the world! :slight_smile: Sounds like we’ll leave tv’s at home, at least in the beginning.</p>

<p>Oooh, Countingdown…wonder what happened to the Birthright coordinator? With so many kids signing up to go, wonder if it’s better to wait till they’re almost finished with college, rahter than just starting? I guess you just applying until it’s your turn to go!</p>

<p>Another ranking for Elon:
[The</a> 50 Most Beautiful College Campuses - Prettiest Universities](<a href=“http://www.thebestcolleges.org/most-beautiful-campuses/#more-2361]The”>http://www.thebestcolleges.org/most-beautiful-campuses/#more-2361)</p>

<p>Funny thing about “Hulu” is that my husband’s cousin came up with the name for the site. At the time he worked for NBC in NYC and they were sitting in a conference room brainstorming about the new internet site and he came up with the goofy name that stuck. My kids and I love the site, especially when our DVR manages to forget to tape a favorite TV show. Although my kids like to watch shows and DVDs on their computers, boys like to use TVs in their dorm rooms for playing video games. I’m not sure if my son will take a TV since he is not a huge fan of gaming, but he will have to discuss it with his future roommate.</p>

<p>I remember a couple of dorm rooms in my D2’s dorm where the boys lofted their beds as high as possible (leading, no doubt, to daily concussions on the ceiling) then they put theirs desks underneath, so that they could fit a small futon and a huge TV on the other wall!</p>

1 Like

<p>Lol Moltobene! I have the two boys, so in S1’s case he is physically active and I doubt he would ever sit and play video games on a tv. S2 definitely would, but I am encouraging him to also be more active, so sounds like no tv’s in their dorm rooms! I am not a strict mom by any stretch of the imagination, but one thing I never allowed was tv’s in their bedrooms, so I guess this follows the same format. Plus, with other kids bringing tv’s they can make friends with them and watch in their rooms! :)</p>

<p>chocchipcookie: We also had the no TV in the bedroom policy, but lately laptops have managed to get around that mandate in our home ;-). Dorm rooms in a sense are more than bedrooms and substitute for an entire living arrangement. One thing I forgot to mention that my kids used often is an electric, portable water/soup hot pot (Proctor Silex.) They used this often in the winter, especially when they got sick! Just make sure to remind them to unplug it! It kept the food and water much hotter than the microwave. BTW, if you have an active Hillel, they will deliver hot chicken soup if your kid is sick!</p>