<p>Um, have you ladies looked at how many foreclosures there are in your area, whichever area that may be, and how high unemployment has been?</p>
<p>Not sure I understand your point - are you saying there is a correlation between foreclosure rates and college matriculation? Not following you.</p>
<p>I think “we” (as in on this board, probably living more comfortably) all assume our kids will go to college. But I didn’t see the Dear Abby article as about that. This student wanted to go to the private school they had gotten into and they were resentful that the parents would only send them to state school. For a lot of people, that’s a reality. Those of us who are able to send our kids to any school, whether paying for it or helping them find loans etc, are more the minority then the majority. Some people are more self indulgent and will go on far flung trips or buy fancy cars rather then pay for their kids to go to an expensive college. More people simply can’t afford to send their kids to whatever school they want.
Personally, I think we should encourage more kids to go to tech schools or learn a trade. Our country is based on people who are plumbers, electricians, laborers, mechanics and factory workers. Not every kid is right for college and the ones who aren’t- there’s a big world waiting for them still. Every kid who wants to go to college and try hard should be able to go. But not every kid needs to go to a college to be successful</p>
<p>My point was a lot of people are struggling just to get by. Not everyone can afford it.</p>
<p>Ok - understood.</p>
<p>This is from an April 2011 Bureau of Labor statistics release:</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>What would be interesting is to compare that with the percentage of Jewish 2010 hs graduates enrolled in college. I have seen estimates of 85% - but not from a very reliable source. Of course - identifying who is a Jewish hs grad is difficult - and some ultra-Orthodox Jewish families might have a different approach. </p>
<p>And then there are the economic issues - as pointed out by Deborah T.</p>
<p>fourkidsmom - agree with you. Did not read Dear Abby. I think many of us on this thread, myself included, are cost-sensitive. Many of our conversations have included discussion of FA and merit aid. But not attending college - not an option I would consider for my kids.</p>
<p>Interesting website:</p>
<p>[The</a> Institute for Jewish and Community Research](<a href=“http://www.jewishresearch.org/quad/0411.html]The”>http://www.jewishresearch.org/quad/0411.html)</p>
<p>Lots of articles on anti-Semitism on college campuses - anti-Israel protests, etc.</p>
<p>Oops, fourkidsmom:</p>
<p>I guess I didn’t read the article carefully enough. </p>
<p>Without a doubt it makes sense going to the best college fit wise and financially wise for you and your family! That’s why community colleges have been going through the roof with enrollments…to get a higher education while saving the money to use toward the last 2 years of college, or even grad school, if possible!</p>
<p>I also agree with you, fourkidsmom about kids learning trades. Maybe in addition to a degree. My bil has an electrical engineering degree, but is also a master carpenter. He has found a way to make money doing two things he loves and also can fix things around the house easily without hiring someone!</p>
<p>Next time I’ll read the article more thoroughly before posting :)</p>
<p>Thank you RVM, for starting, leading and always posting your research.</p>
<p>Here’s a link to the Dear Abby article:</p>
<p>[Dear</a> Abby on uExpress](<a href=“Dear Abby - Life Advice | UExpress”>Dear Abby - Life Advice | UExpress)</p>
<p>The student wants to attend pricey LACs - but her father is unemployed and is trying to get a job at a large state university - which would give her a 70% tuition discount. She does not want to attend this “party” school and hopes her Dad does not get the job. Abby points out that the family’s financial situation has changed and that large public university is better than nothing.</p>
<p>Hi RVM:</p>
<p>That link was to the original Dear Abby that appeared on April 9th. Today’s column is all in response to that original April 9th letter. Now that I’ve read the column more thoroughly I see it’s a response to this girl’s letter and not about going to college in general, as I first thought.</p>
<p>Right - I saw the responses first - everyone agreed with Dear Abby - hs students not getting much sympathy. Wanted to post the original letter to clarify. </p>
<p>Although I have to say - just browsing through the CC Parent Forum - there are a few threads now debating the wisdom and value of going to college.</p>
<p>For many decades college graduates could assume that they would find a “career” once they finished their degree. This article in today’s New York Times <a href=“http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/19/business/economy/19grads.html[/url]”>http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/19/business/economy/19grads.html</a> indicates that such an assumption is no longer valid in the current economic climate. When my D1 graduated in 2009, very few of her classmates and other kids who have graduated since then, have found jobs in the fields in which they majored in college. Many are working in low level, often very boring, jobs. She was extremely lucky to land an interesting, well paying job in NYC. She has tried to find jobs for her friends and often walks their resumes into the HR office at her firm. None have found jobs yet.
This article highlights one big problem, that when you graduate and take a bartending or clerk/office job, often this becomes your resume and it is hard to sell your skill set to an employer. My D1 spent two summers during college working at great internships (one paid, one not when she worked 2 jobs) and she feels this is what gave her a leg up in the job hunt. So keep in mind that once your kids go to college, summer internships are KEY to future employment.</p>
<p>Thank you for posting that - very sobering. I agree with you completely on the importance of summer jobs and internships that add to the resume. Also - minimizing student loan debt is another critical factor.</p>
<p>Rockvillemom: I absolutely agree that minimizing debt is a huge factor. We have told our kids that we will cover the cost of their undergraduate degrees and this gives them the freedom to take risks with a job or move to another city after graduation. Many of D1’s friends, who do not have high paying jobs, are encumbered with rent, car expenses and now they have the monthly bill for their college loans. I am also seeing a lot of kids taking jobs for the salary where the employer gives them either no benefits, such as medical coverage or in one case they pay for medical, but do not provide any paid days off, other than a few holidays. It is a very tough job market out there.</p>
<p>There is another thread about this article and parents are highlighting that business, science and engineering majors tend to do well in job hunting, but that traditional liberal arts majors do not. Too bad I absolutely hated my one and only accounting class in college and science and math were like a foreign language to me. As with many students in today’s world, you have to go the grad school route if you like the humanities. Law school for me, Phd in psychology for my nephew, masters in counseling for a friend’s daughter. A degree in psych or political science won’t give you great results anymore straight out of college, unless of course, you worked for Hillary Clinton in the state department during the summer. D2’s friend who majored in “defense studies” at Georgetown landed a consulting job with a big 8 accounting firm because of the great internship she had with Clinton in college.</p>
<p>Hope what I wrote didn’t sound short. That wasn’t the intention. I was writing quickly, needing to leave to transport kid to work this morning. Probably should have waited until later when I could take more time composing. </p>
<p>And happy thread anniversary, lol! :)</p>
<p>I love this thread. I raise my glass to its founders and all of its contributors. To me its like a much needed coffee after dinner, where the conversation runs freely.</p>
<p>How bad is it if we don’t look at schools and just apply? Costs are high with gas and hotels etc. Is there other ways to show interest?</p>
<p>UMCP has moved back to the apply list. We are on the bubble I think for a Spring admit. Should we try for a dedicated program or mark undecided?</p>
<p>Cherryhillmom: I think that college visits are very important. My daughters changed their opinions on several schools after visiting. The did each apply to a few schools without visiting, and we planned to visit after acceptance if they were in the running. I would try to visit as many of the convenient schools as you can. If you can’t visit, check the schools websites to see if they are having any receptions in your area. You can attend those to get a feel for the school and “show the love.” </p>
<p>A neighbor who is a college professor recently told me that how many times a student visits is the biggest indicator of whether they will attend. I found that interesting.</p>
<p>For UMDCP I would recommend applying for a specific program if you child has a strong leaning. If he’s trying to decide between more than one area, have him apply to the one that is less popular. Maryland has a lot of limited majors (business, journalism, psych, criminolgy,etc) and it can be hard to get into one of these majors later on. My friend whose daughter is in Freshman Connection (spring admit) says that most of the kids in that program seem to be undecided. I’m not sure it that was factor.</p>
<p>cherryhill - I agree that it makes sense to visit if at all possible - both to see if student actually likes the school and to show demonstrated interest. I thought S2 would be applying to CofC - now after visiting - he is not doing so. But if the school is just too far - then I would try to attend a regional event if there is one and/or have your child at least meet the admissions rep if they visit your hs and/or meet the rep at a college fair.</p>
<p>I was actually looking at University of Miami today - thinking that maybe we could at least look into it - they are having a regional info session at a hotel near us in 2 weeks. Asked S2 if he was interested in spending the 2 hours to attend the presentation - and he was not. But - if things change in the fall and he wants to apply - he will do so sight unseen. But for demonstrated interest purposes - he is on the mailing list and maybe they will have another regional session in the fall. Apparently I can neither lead this horse to water nor make him drink!</p>
<p>moltobene - what I find interesting is that for every article that advises college students to go with a professional major such as business, computer science or engineering - you can find another one advising that employers prefer liberal arts graduates who can write, think and analyze. I am hoping that by majoring in finance with a minor in political science - S1 has both scenarios covered! I am encouraging S2 to follow a similar model - practical major and liberal arts minor. </p>
<p>Deborah T - your comment earlier was more puzzling than short - but it’s no big deal - we were on a tangent anyway.</p>
<p>RVM-We were going to go to the Long Island session of Miami last week but couldn’t make it. A friend went and said it was very informative but poorly attended.</p>