<p>RVM, for the record, there may have been BMWs and a Mercedes in our driveway at various times (as well as Subaru, Isuzu and VWs) and my kids’ collars are only blue when they pick them out that way at the Mall, but their employers -both summer and full-time - have been more than pleased with their work ethics, independent thinking, intelligence and creativity.</p>
<p>I realize you were only reporting what the Pamplin rep said, but I just had this exact conversation last night with my S who came back from Spain sunday and is going in for job interviews this week. It’s not the wealth, but the upbringing that leads to a desireable work ethic. And there are many other advantages to employers in a number of businesses and industries to hiring “sophisticated” and even advantaged, but not spoiled, young men and women.</p>
<p>Hey y’all, Son just found out he was accepted into the Michigan Research Community (MRC) living in the Mosher-Jordan dorm. Are any of the Michigan bound kids on this site doing this learning community? He got his football tickets yesterday and leaves Friday for his job as a counselor at a sleep-away camp, so things are moving along this summer.</p>
<p>Okay people, so what about the sophisticated, poor, Mercedes driving, good work ethic student attending VT? What do you make of him? What if he has both white shirts and ones with blue collars in his closet? And btw, just how much is the insurance on his Mercedes anyway?</p>
<p>mhc - I agree with you that the upbringing is the important factor as you can find upper middle class kids with a Mercedes in the driveway and a good work ethic and you can also find lower income kids with no car in the driveway who are lazy. But I do think that many times when colleges are described - the relative wealth of the student body is noted and is relevant. I’m sure we have all read descriptions of schools like Univ. of Miami or Tulane that describe wealthy east coast students, their cars, their designer clothes, handbags and sunglasses, etc.</p>
<p>The Pamplin speaker at VT was expressing pride in their students - many of whom come from a more middle class/blue collar background and that prospective employers have been impressed with VT graduates and their values and work ethic. I would not take that to mean that said employers were only impressed with VT grads and did not also recruit at wealthier schools like UVA. She was merely explaining that VT grads do well in the job market. She used the phrase “blue collar work ethic” and in that context - it made sense. No one is saying that white collar kids cannot or do not also possess a good work ethic. I think VT takes a lot of pride in who they are - and who they are not. There is a very down-to-earth quality to the school and to the student body. Frankly, I found it refreshing.</p>
<p>Actually, RVM, that middle middle class, “blue collar”, will-do, attitude was the vibe I felt at JMU. It was one of the (unfortunately few) things that strongly attracted me to the school.</p>
<p>But I think it’s something you’d find at many State funded universities, simply because the children of blue collar or lower income parents can attend due to the lower in-state tuition and other initiatives to bring them in. And many will have a drive to achieve and do better than their parents</p>
<p>On the otherhand, I’ve also read of friction, antipathy or distance between those students and wealthier, out of state students who attend some state schools (Wisconsin is a prime example), which if encountered might make it less welcoming for your son (or someone possibly percieved to be different from those students) to attend.</p>
<p>Also (and admittedly this is anectodal), I’ve heard lots of stories and tales of woe from parents of kids who went to the second tier of SUNY’s or even first tier but who were in the middle of their class, who did not get good internships or did not fare well in the post grad job market. Partly because employers recruited more at more prestigious universities. Partly because less outstanding students there were passed over. </p>
<p>Finally, with all respect to the Pamplin rep, who was of course touting his school, I can’t help but wonder what level of employer recruits at Pamplin (mostly regional?) and for what kinds of post grad job? Did they hand out a list of companies that come there, like many schools do?</p>
<p>Deborah - thanks for the VT info - very interesting to see a list like that.</p>
<p>mhc - agree with you that was also the vibe at JMU. I think that vibe is something that appeals to S2 - it’s a little hard to define - but we know it when we see it/feel it. It’s casual clothes - rather than designer/preppy style. It’s hanging out with friends on campus rather than going to a club off campus. It’s the availability of bus transportation home - rather than checking if the campus allows freshmen to have cars, and so forth.</p>
<p>I don’t want to generalize too much - but we have talked extensively on this thread about fit - and I think there is a socioeconomic component to it. As you pointed out - being a wealthy OOS student at a public university has its own share of problems - as does being a middle class, public school educated, FA receiving student at a private university filled with wealthy students. Just something to consider.</p>
<p>This Jewish family has two parents who were zero EFC college students (one state school, one Ivy, both were fairly miserable experiences socioeconomically) and have raised our kids with the understanding that our family’s FA package would not include vehicles and that it would include Staffords and work during the school year and summers, regardless of what our EFC is. Our blue collar roots run very deep.</p>
<p>They have noticed their college campuses are a lot less diverse and a lot wealthier than where we live. It makes them uncomfortable. They felt a lot more grounded at their semi-urban public high schools.</p>
<p>It’s an interesting issue. We are by no means low income (except perhaps in the world of college FA) but also have no interest in the rat race of conspicuous consumption. S1 attends a pricey private university and receives substantial need based FA. If it bothers him that so many of his friends are from wealthier families - he has not let on. On the contrary - he has had some fun experiences courtesy of friends with beach homes and so forth.</p>
<p>I think the truth of the matter is that the financial disparity may bother me more. As I mentioned upthread - I hate needing FA. I appreciate it - but also find it somewhat humiliating. There is an appeal to me at schools like JMU and VT about not feeling “less than”.</p>
<p>We set a guideline early on for S2 that there would be no $50,000+ plus schools on his list. While I may have wavered on that from time to time, I do want to stick to it - for many reasons. I think there are enough options available at a reasonable pricetag and with a student body that includes a range of family incomes.</p>
<p>I love reading this thread even though I don’t contribute very often.</p>
<p>I just wanted to say that I just returned from my middle son’s graduation from the University of Denver. It’s still a very good choice for a B to B+ Jewish student, although not on the eastern seaboard–still, Denver is an easy flight from just about anywhere. The school is not cheap but there is both good merit aid and FA available.</p>
<p>Our family had a wonderful Shabbos lunch at the campus Chabad…very welcoming, no religious pressure at all…and packed with a lot of kids from various backgrounds and practices…the rabbi and rebbetzin each seemed to know each kid’s life story and what made them tick.</p>
<p>There is a good amount of Jewish opportunity on the campus.</p>
<p>My son seriously considered continuing there for graduate school because he has enjoyed it so much.</p>
<p>Okay people, so what about the sophisticated, poor, Mercedes driving, good work ethic student attending VT? What do you make of him? What if he has both white shirts and ones with blue collars in his closet? And btw, just how much is the insurance on his Mercedes anyway?</p>
<p>Deborah, the kid you mentioned in #8243 is driving his parents’ ten year old Mercedes that they had to replace with a Hyundai two years ago due to temporary financial difficulties in his dad’s business. Most of the the blue or white shirts in his closet don’t have any collars: he likes tees. The two that do have collars (which his Mom bought at Kohls for 30% off and $10 in Kohls cash) he only wears at his part time campus job in the admissions office.</p>
<p>And the Mercedes is so old that there’s no need for collision anymore and as a B+ student he qualifies for a good student discount, so even at his age, insurance is fairly cheap.</p>
<p>I was just curious how things are in other parts of the country since some of you mentioned students working summers. S1 fortunately has a part time paid intership but since he is doing study abroad in the fall and will therefore not work during that semester as he normally would, not to mention that I expect he will want more spending money than he normally does on campus, we were hoping that he would get another job for a few hours per week to supplement the internship income. The thing is, so far no one seems to be hiring summer help.So far on the interviews he has had when people hear he is leaving in the fall they say never mind. Have your kids had a similar experience?</p>
<p>spectrum, at least your son is going away for the fall semester, not the spring. So at minimum he will get the part time summer internship now and will be in a good position to find something for next summer. My son just came back from his spring semester abroad and although he had a lot of responses when he contacted employers in January, once they heard that he was following up from abroad and could not come in for an interview, those summer jobs went nowhere. Your son won’t have that problem for next summer.</p>
<p>The good, and surprising thing, was that a semester abroad need not be all that expensive and he might not need as much spending money abroad as you think. It depends a lot on where he is going, some countries cost a lot less. 16 credits in Seville was so cheap that even with all his travels around the continent, the cost of the entire semester abroad turned out to be less than half the cost of tuition and room and board had he remained in Michigan for the Spring. </p>
<p>Fortunately for my son, he has one interview this week and the company he interned at last summer liked him so much they’ve said they will make a paid position for him if the other job falls through.</p>
<p>Deborah, the two things I found surprising about the stats you found were the remarkably few number of “Liberal Arts” majors reporting or having jobs and the large number of students going into the military or gov’t. Maybe I shouldn’t have been surprised given that it’s Virginia and that it’s Va Tech.</p>
<p>“although he had a lot of responses when he contacted employers in January, once they heard that he was following up from abroad and could not come in for an interview, those summer jobs went nowhere”</p>
<p>this was my daughter’s experience as well…but I will take it to one more level…</p>
<p>Two of the firms she was in contact with encouraged her to continue the process with phone interviews…what ended up happening, though, was that they ended up hiring ONLY the students who could come in for the interviews…so for your students who will go abroad, you never know…but keep this in mind (my d had no idea that this was the case, not that it would have changed her plans)</p>
<p>She ended up in a paid internship with a large adv agency that acknowledged UP FRONT that they had created an interview process for kids who study abroad (a two hour skype interview)…</p>
<p>was an interesting learning experience though…</p>
<p>D1 and I have talked about this. She’s attended public schools with incredibly diverse socioeconomics. She’s had friends who come from great wealth, and friends whose parents couldn’t afford to pay for vaccinations. She’s read how some of the incoming freshmen at her college are looking forward to moving to a campus more diverse than their high schools, but she’ll be going somewhere less diverse. Advantages and disadvantages.</p>