Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Since this university is back on S2’s list - was just refreshing my memory - they do have a very active Hillel - over 2000 Jewish students and a chapter of Jewish fraternity AEPi. Also noticed they are having a program for incoming freshmen in August:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s nice to see something like this - makes me less nervous about the possibility of a large university such as VT.</p>

<p>A new Hillel blog I just came across:</p>

<p>[JMU</a> Hillel](<a href=“http://jmuhillel.blogspot.com/]JMU”>http://jmuhillel.blogspot.com/)</p>

<p>And the AEPi website:</p>

<p><a href=“http://jmuaepi.org/[/url]”>http://jmuaepi.org/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Great info. Thanks Rockville :)</p>

<p>Hope all the dads had a great day.</p>

<p>Emmy, I looked in to Coastal. Did not visit. Spoke with Dean of Business School who at the time was the Hillel advisor. Very small Hillel. Too small for us to consider looking. At that time, we took Coastal off the list and put UNC Greensboro on to look at, which has a wonderful music dept and beautiful campus not in the middle of the city. Nice for B students, good cost and 200 students in Hillel.</p>

<p>JMU-there is a parent on this thread, can’t remember, whose son is the president of the AEpi. Maybe he will chime in. S was in touch with another member who was very friendly and was going to meet us when we visit. Also Hillel VP was quite nice. Just email the kids and they will go to lunch with you, have coffee and meet for another perspective. RVM if you go during the open house, maybe you can end the day with coffee with the AEpi guys.</p>

<p>RVM, glad to see vt back on list. It looks awesome from a Jewish perspective. If my S wanted a larger school it would be on our list for sure.</p>

<p>SoCal makes sense for you to look at JMU this trip if you are coming east. One thing I can say when we researched JMU is that there is a spirit on campus that seems to pervade through all its materials. We have a close friend who was accepted to several schools and found the students so cheery that she chose JMU.</p>

<p>As for S’s process, he will write his personal essay in July, his Elon specific essay in August and fill out the app. I think you have gathered that if I tell him to do it, he will! Yes I am lucky that way, but he does realize that once classes begin in the fall, he will have very little time to get the essays done. He is taking a business law class at our local community college, and working full time as a lifeguard, so I am hoping that time management kicks in. I must admit he has kept his own calendar this week, so his executive secretary (me!) has had a little vacation.</p>

<p>Evidently, this past year DH and S had chosen a theme “to do my best.” I just found this out and it seems that S thought about this throughout the year and it really did make a difference. He is ending the year with 5 As (A+ in enviro science), B+ and a B. This is in comparison to only 2 As last year. What a turnaround. </p>

<p>So S told me about his theme for the next year: responsibility. Sounds good to me. Certainly working full time fits the bill. Let’s see how much he steps up to the plate versus how much I have to nag him.</p>

<p>I want to wish all the graduates a Yasher Koach, good luck to the rising seniors beginning essays, and a deep breath to all us moms and dads!</p>

1 Like

<p>Choosing a theme - hmmm…wonder if S2 would consider this. He is still quite uninterested and unmotivated in this process. I pointed out to him that he was more focused and engaged in his conversation with the oral surgeon the other day regarding having his wisdom teeth pulled!! And he laughed and acknowledged it was true. </p>

<p>I have asked him to spend some time the next few weeks looking at college material - on-line, brochures, whatever he wants to do. He agreed to do so - but I have seen no signs of it as of yet. My only comfort is that most of his friend’s mothers are having the same issue - so at least it is not just him.</p>

<p>rvm- responding to one of your posts a few pages back about strategies for getting college applications in shape over the summer. My D will be home this summer, and luckily her SAT tutor also serves as a college counselor and will meet with her and get her organized and working on her personal essay and activity resume. She will be applying to some rolling admissions schools so she will need to have those apps together in early September. Getting this done over the summer will take the pressure off in the fall when all the other kids are struggling with their college applications she should be basically done!</p>

<p>We all have the same boys - hmmm :frowning: but they are so darn cute :)</p>

<p>and- here is my D’s college counselor’s to do list for summer to get ready for the fall application process:</p>

<ol>
<li> Write a resume - helps to organize information before dealing with the rigidity of application forms, and will be sent along with applications - a great process for parents and students! </li>
<li> Write the two essays required on The Common Application </li>
<li> Complete The Common Application </li>
<li> Decide on further testing - Fall ACT or SAT? </li>
<li> Settle on a hard list of schools and plan for Fall visits </li>
<li> Research and chart admissions options - varied criteria and requirements, deadlines, early action, early decision, etc. </li>
<li> Write supplemental essays </li>
<li> Select people to write your letters of recommendation and draft a quick, but specific, note of request</li>
</ol>

<p>That’s a nice to-do list. The only thing I’d change is to ask teachers for recs at the end of the junior year, not the start of senior year. That’s because at some schools the teachers are so overwhelmed by requests that all of their available “slots” fill up in the spring. But this depends on your own school’s culture.</p>

<p>One of the things I’m very very grateful for about USY and our synagogue’s USY advisor is that the members need to have a “brag sheet” if they’re running for office, or applying for a position or a scholarship. They’re supposed to list all of their ECs and volunteer activities, both within the Jewish community, at school, or anywhere else. Both my kids ended up maintaining their own activities resume on their own because of USY. It worked out much better than waiting until the summer before senior year to assemble the list of activities, and it was also much easier than having us nag the D’s to write it all down.</p>

<p>“2. Write the two essays required on The Common Application”</p>

<p>There are two essays? I thought there was only one! Oh no!</p>

<p>MDmom: The common ap has a choice of one 500 word essay, and a very short essay about an EC.</p>

<p>Great list Pamom!</p>

<p>In case you all think that the essays end with applications, my D needs to write one to apply for a pre-orientation program at her college.</p>

<p>Samtayla: When you called Coastal; - Dean of Business School and others that you have mentioned, how are your calls received? I mean, I am sure that they are going to give you correct information and IMO anyone who calls (parent student community member) should be given due diligence - that’s customer service 101, but do you not feel that this is something our students should be doing? </p>

<p>I could see me compiling a list of questions with my son to ask, but I think I would feel very uncomfortable calling and talking to a Dean. Am I missing an opportunity here? or should I stick with my gut that while I am involved in the steering of this journey, I really feel it is his responsibility to determine the destination.</p>

<p>A list addition for art students:</p>

<p>Look over portfolio requirements for schools under consideration. Work on additional pieces that will be needed, and figure out what format you will use to submit your portfolio. </p>

<p>I imagine music students will be doing similar work preparing for auditions or becoming familiar with any necessary materials that will need to be assembled and submitted.</p>

<p>Arts supplement.</p>

<p>For anyone who is unfamiliar with the common app and will have a student submitting it for the first time, be aware there are college specific supplements for many schools that may require additional essays (as pamom mentioned) or short answers.</p>

<p>Coastal Carolina is on my d’s list. They offer many, many majors she is interested in. Plus, it really is a true B students school. I know there are Jewish congregations in nearby Myrtle Beach. In fact, it would be a great school for someone who wants to be near the beach and golf courses but in non-urban area. I wouldn’t think, though, that it has a big OOS population, but I could be wrong about that.</p>

<p>I do know one Jewish student there and his mom reports that he is very, very happy.</p>

<p>Thanks for the info regarding the second essay on an EC. Do they usually write about an EC that is related to their major or an EC that shows other interests. I can see going either way with it. </p>

<p>Soon as the kids leave for camp, I will pull up the preliminary common ap and start going through it. If I tell D there is one more essay for the common ap, I think her head may explode right now! I will be happy enough if she wraps up the main essay and finishes her resume this week. </p>

<p>Regarding any contact with schools. D likes to email and so far that has worked. All questions have come from her email. We may work on a draft together, but it all goes through her.</p>

<p>Thanks Levrim for the thread. I can’t wait to read it. Love the list PAmom. Our kids had to do a junior questionnaire and Dd finished that today. It has a resume attached, so that is done too. I do have a question though. How do the kids start the essay for the common app if it does not come out until August 1st?</p>

<p>mdmom - the “second essay” is really just a paragraph - on an EC. I think it has a 1500 character limit - which is about 150 - 200 words perhaps. I would choose an EC that is different from anything they discussed in their main essay - but other than that - any EC towards the top of their resume should be fine.</p>

<p>philly - re CA essay - you can go to the CA website and see a preview copy of the 2011-2012 application which includes the 6 essay choices, one of which is topic of your choice. The essay will be done as a Word document which you will upload into the CA. So - they can start now - doing the essay as a Word document - and then it is ready for August when you can actually create the CA account and start filling it out online.</p>

<p>Here is the link for the 2011-2012 preview Common Application:</p>

<p><a href=“https://www.commonapp.org/CommonApp/Docs/DownloadForms/2012-11CAO_Highlighted.pdf[/url]”>https://www.commonapp.org/CommonApp/Docs/DownloadForms/2012-11CAO_Highlighted.pdf&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>We printed it out and have started filling it in to save time later. There are a few things - like Social Security number and the CEEB codes for where the parents went to college - that we had to stop and find - so it will be nice to have all info on this form already when August rolls around.</p>

<p>For parents that have younger kids and haven’t been through the application process yet…one thing I’m very glad we did was to keep a notebook of each child’s EC’s each year of high school. The notebook is divided with a section for each kid and a list of activities both in and out of the school. And work experiences both paid & volunteer.</p>

<p>So when it came time to add them to the applications, it was much easier to have them all in one place to refer to. The older one also had Nat’l Honor Soc. and used the notebook list to fill the pages of his NHS application too. We have refered to the notebook lists many times for many applications, including scholarships, etc.</p>

<p>Slitheytove: my S did not get into the pre-orientation. Did your D? </p>

<p>Momjr: Cannot believe they have to write an essay for that! :frowning: Jeez!</p>

<p>cherryhill: i first emailed advisor of hillel of coastal. found email address on hillel natl website. he emailed me back and then we spoke. the contact was well received and i felt the dean was wonderful. if there were more jews, i would have had S look. </p>

<p>as for contacting schools, my feeling is that if it is a general inquiry it is ok for parents to contact. if it is specific questions once your S has made initial contact and is interested in the school, then he should contact hillel and admissions rep. now in saying that when it came to visits and arranging for S to sit in on classes, meet professors, attend seder S made initial contact and i chimed in to do the logistics.</p>

<p>i had meetings this morning and returned to find S doing summer honors constitution class work and outline of essay. wow. day 1 of vacation success. lucky me! will this last through next week?</p>

<p>RVM, thank you for the link to the draft Common App. It’s interesting to see the changes from the year before marked in yellow. Some of the changes (ie re reporting of disciplinary violations - a potentially important bit of info) highlight how complicated our world has become.</p>

<p>It’s inspiring to read the summer to-do lists and progress reports. Well, maybe a little intimidating, too. My D’s summer is off and running. She’s made a few more college visits (including two interviews), but is definitely still honing the list. She truly believes that she’ll be happy wherever she’s planted, but we’re also still holding on to the goal of finding the best fit. After going through this with D1, we know that there are pros and cons to every school. D2 has more of a mixed bag of ‘credentials’, but also has a lot of energy and enthusiasm and will make the most of the available opportunities.</p>

<p>Congratulations to all the graduates and good luck to those still in HS (especially the '12s)! I look forward to following everyone’s progress here.</p>