Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>I’ve heard that some schools that offer Merit Aid and did not require the FAFSA in the past are now requiring it. A friend of a friend just found out that she needed to submit an FAFSA in order to get the merit money for the coming year.</p>

<p>Don’t know if this is a trend to help schools that are experiencing budget shortfalls, i.e., by finding ways to shed merit aid.</p>

<p>“U-Mich used to recalculate GPAs to take away weighting, but changed that last year and now will look at whatever GPA is shown on the transcript.”</p>

<p>Does anyone have a feel for how many other schools only look at the reported GPA? </p>

<p>This is a little concerning since weighting can really vary all over the place. I think my S’s high school only reports the unweighted! :(</p>

<p>It seems to be the publics that look at whatever is on the transcript. U of Oregon (B-student appropriate) will look at whatever is printed on the transcript, W or UW, and take whatever’s higher. 911C2S, maybe worth asking your high school or district to change their policy? Bring it up at a PTA/Booster Club meeting? Hell hath no fury like parents thinking that the high school’s policy is causing their kid to get rejected from colleges. :)</p>

<p>UC and CSU famously do their own calculation, as an exception to the above. Not sure if this is true for any other public. </p>

<p>I bought a copy of D1’s official transcript at the end of junior year to check on what it showed. Weirdly, there was no GPA printed at all! I never asked about that, because then I’d have to admit to opening the seal on the official transcript. Kinda like ripping off the mattress tag. ;)</p>

<p>Am I correct in thinking that spectrum’s school does not weight because it is in Texas, with the statewide policy of the top 10% getting admission to the state schools, so an attempt to create “equity”?</p>

<p>“It seems to be the publics that look at whatever is on the transcript.”</p>

<p>Interestingly, my impression, based on some recent Google searches, is just the opposite, but I don’t feel I really have enough information to be certain.</p>

<p>Check out this whole thread. I’ve linked to a couple of my posts.
<a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/12788136-post72.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/12788136-post72.html&lt;/a&gt;
<a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/12871721-post84.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/12871721-post84.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>It seems like a number of publics do recalculate. Various selective privates may not but are trying to look at a holistic picture.</p>

<p>CHmom: i just went back and looked at my post and realized it was deceiving; I was referring to UMich at over $52,000 (the post was from screen name Entertainer)…from what friends have told me, Penn State is around $42,000 for OOS…</p>

<p>sorry about that; didn’t want to make you lose sleep!!!</p>

<p>btw, are there any other publics (other than UDel) who have increased OOS tuition this year by a much larger % than instate?..jw since alot of them are on lists here…
I completely understand the logic on the part of the schools; just want to have a complete picture before Sept rush…</p>

<p>Deborah T, so much for my impression! And thank heavens for weasel words. :)</p>

<p>Thank you all for the replies. I plan to compile a list of schools which seem to have policies that would point to the absence of WGPA being detrimental to admission and scholarships and email the information along with the school links to the very involved parents that I know. Let me know if any other schools come to mind. </p>

<p>ST, I don’t know about the “hell hath no fury…” here in the Lone Star State. We’ll see, I haven’t yet met a single parent who realized there was a change and our registrar confirmed to me that I was the first to question this. </p>

<p>I don’t see this as having a large impact on my S2 other than him not getting the pat on the back feeling you get when you see the WGPA. He is most likely going to a state school which is all about rank not GPA. If the change had occurred when S1 was applying to schools I would have felt a much more personal sense of frustration. It is just knowing about what S1 went through in the application process that makes me sad for other students in a similar position. Our district has very few students going to OOS schools and even fewer getting into highly competitve schools.</p>

<p>Levirm: Interestingly enough weight does count into calculation of rank, just not GPA as it appears on the transcript. It also happens all of the time that one student will have a lower GPA and higher class rank and that was even when weighted GPA’s were on the transcript. I believe this is because rank just includes core classes and GPA includes everything but I have always found this confusing. At least within the the scope of the districts that I am aware of Texas schools do list weighted GPA’s and ours did until last year. This change happened without explanation so I don’t know why it happened, I can only speculate based on the things I have heard from out district administration regarding their respect for weighting AP and preAP classes. That also makes me sad because I know how much harder many of those classes are.</p>

<p>“And thank heavens for weasel words.”</p>

<p>So true, lol.</p>

<p>“I plan to compile a list of schools which seem to have policies that would point to the absence of WGPA being detrimental to admission and scholarships and email the information along with the school links to the very involved parents that I know.”</p>

<p>Spectrum, have you found many schools like this thus far?</p>

<p>Deborah T:Hummm, well I have been thinking about this for while, it was one of RVM’s posts that got me going on this yesterday. That and some literature I received from the U of South Carolina recently. I do plan to go back to each website I include in my e mail but for now and largely based on information that has been provided on this thread this is my list to do further research on:
Univ of South Carolina; York; Indiana University Bloomington; University of Miami; West Virginia University;U of Michigan. I hope I haven’t missed any. </p>

<p>Thanks for the links Deborah, I think I need to look further at that GPA calculation link that you had posted on.</p>

<p>oops, I missed U of Oregon.</p>

<p>spectrum: UMiami re: merit scholarships are largely based on class rank v GPA…in addition, I think that they prefer an UW GPA just so you know…merit cut-offs are around the equiv of a 30 ACT (but without the class rank, not so much)…I personally know kids with high SAT/ACT’s, but lower class ranks (15-20%) that were offered zilch…</p>

<p>UMich: they change their policy hourly but the last update was that they take whatever GPA is presented on the transcript and evaluate w honors/AP classes…GPA rules here (not SAT/ACT)…</p>

<p>Same with Indiana; from my observations, though, SAT/ACT is more important to them than GPA…they do, however, use the transcript GPA…</p>

<p>hope this helps.>>></p>

<p>With all this WGPA talk, I’ve been playing around with DS’ final grades and trying to calculate. Just major subjects and foreign language. How do you figure in a half year science elective? Same as if it were a whole year?</p>

<p>Sent from my ADR6300 using CC App</p>

<p>^no; multiply everything that’s a year X2 and only count the semester elective as X1…then divide by total…</p>

<p>For ex: 5 core year long X2= 10 plus the half year +11…</p>

<p>if it was all A’s for example: 4.0 x2= 8.0 point value for each full year
4.0 X1=4.0 for the half year</p>

<p>Re: University of Miami merit aid-- there is a new thread where students are posting SAT/act. Gpa, rank and their merit aid. Rank does seem to be a factor. I’m sure it will motivate DS. I’m going to
save for him. P.S. he landed in Tel Aviv last night so his Israeli adventure is underway!</p>

<p>Sent from my ADR6300 using CC App</p>

<p>Thanks Rodney. I will have to try that. </p>

<p>Sent from my ADR6300 using CC App</p>

<p>Rodney- Our HS doesn’t rank (re: Miami). Too many brainiacs who are .00001 away from the kid ranked ahead of them. Are we at a disadvantage?</p>

<p>Our transcripts show both weighted and unweighted. We have the choice to show rank as well as the choice to have the high school show test scores.</p>

<p>Vitrac - our large public school system - the 14th largest in the country I believe - does not rank either and I have not heard of any problems. I think that unless you are at the top of the class - ranking hurts more kids than it helps.</p>

<p>We had 21 of 37 who applied to Miami accepted. I don’t feel they penalize a student in terms of awarding merit aid if their school does not rank - they just go by GPA and test scores.</p>

<p>From the University of Miami website:</p>

<p>

</code></pre>

<p>No mention of class rank that I can see.</p>