Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>peonies- I have a good friend whose daughter was deciding between Pitt and Muhlenberg- she decided to attend Muhlenberg so she could participate in the D3 sports there, and it turned out to be a great decision for her, she played Varsity Lacrosse as a freshman. Our school sends a number of kids to Muhlenberg every year, and they all seem very happy. By the way, she is not “artsy.” I think if your kid is going to be on a sports team, she will have a ready made social network. </p>

<p>F&M is also very popular with kids from our school, especially kids who are on the swim team. Based on visits- F&M seemed like the “preppier” of the two schools. Also, I think that Lancaster is a nicer area than Allentown. But, depending on where you live, Allentown might be more convenient to drive to.</p>

<p>If your D is interested in sports, I think the most important thing is going to be meeting the coaches.</p>

<p>I’m sure that you are also aware that most LACs accept a higher percentage of students from their ED pool. Fortunately, both Muhlenberg and F&M offer late rounds of ED- Muhlenberg’s is Feb. 15 F&M has two rounds: ED I is Nov 15 and ED II is Jan 15.</p>

<p>pamom, thanks for the great suggestions. A cousin is a Muhlenberg grad (30 years ago) and his education has served him well as an MD. We also have a relative who is currently happy at F & M. My D has been away for much of the month of July and we do need to focus more on honing the list (ie find time to focus more …). About ED, I agree that the two rounds offer students some nice flexibility if they aren’t sure by November, or if they have an unsuccessful result in ED I. ED is very appealing to my D, though the challenge is finding a college that she loves AND has a reasonable chance in admissions.</p>

<p>orangemom, good luck to your student! Even though it’s the students who are applying to colleges, it’s nice to know that we’re all in this together as we try to support them as best we can.</p>

<p>peonies- on the admission issue- it may be helpful to know that both F&M and Muhlenberg offer SAT optional admissions. My impression is that Muhlenberg is a little less competitive in admissions than F&M. </p>

<p>Muhlenberg SAT optional policy:</p>

<p>“If you submit test scores, we ask for the SAT-I or ACT. Since 1996, Muhlenberg has offered prospective freshmen the option of not submitting their SAT or ACT scores, and approximately 10-15% of our applicant pool takes advantage of this option each year. If you opt not to send your scores, you’ll need to have a personal interview and submit the SAT-optional form, as well as a graded paper from 11th or 12th grade with the teacher’s grade and comments included (no poems or mathematical formulas, please). We also honor AP credit. One final note, if you’re applying for a cooperative program or wish to be considered for merit scholarships, you must submit test scores.”</p>

<p>Franklin & Marshall SAT optional policy:</p>

<p>"Students who do not believe their standardized test scores reflect their academic ability are able to submit two graded writing samples to Franklin & Marshall in lieu of standardized test scores.</p>

<p>Students choosing the Standardized Test Option will be required to submit two recent (junior or senior year) graded writing samples (creative or analytical), preferably from a Humanities or social science course. The samples should include teachers’ comments, grades, and a description of the assignment.</p>

<p>Students may request that their high school delete their scores from their transcript. All transcripts for students choosing this option will be examined prior to their inclusion in the application folders, and any scores that are included will be deleted before the applications are reviewed by the Admission Committee.</p>

<p>To choose this option, an applicant must complete the appropriate form which is part of the application, or is sent to the applicant upon receipt of the Common Application. Click here to access the Standardized Test Option Form."</p>

<p>peonies -</p>

<p>Another LAC to consider that has DIII sports is Dickinson. We visited on Monday and were impressed with the campus, the friendliness of the staff and tour guide and many of the facilities, especially the library and the science building. During the info session, they mentioned that they are SAT optional, but suggested that if your SATs fall within their range, it’s probably a good idea to send them. They also said that they don’t require other tests or essay in place of the SAT. And they offer EA.</p>

<p>Peonies, I have to agree with looking again at Muhlenberg and also thinking about Dickinson. Many kids from our school go to Muhlenberg and all seem to be happy and go on to do whatever type of graduate school or job opportunity they are looking for. They are not all artsy at all, but all over the map, from a kid that worked in high school for the EMS to a very geeky kid. As far as Dickinson, I have one friend whose dd was a strong b/ a- student. At Dickinson she had the opportunity to flourish and become an incredible student and learner, I know that she took some hebrew and other Jewish theory class. She has gone on to Princeton Seminary (she’s not Jewish), and she is at the top of her class there too and very successful. I loved the campus when I saw it and if you are looking at F&M and other LAC’s here it might be a great fit, although I don’t know about the sports–not happening in this house! :)</p>

<p>re: Muhlenberg ED: just a note; unlike most, if not all, schools, their ED does not have a specific deadline until Feb 15th; meaning that you can apply ED at any time from Sept-Feb…</p>

<p>I’ll chime in re: Georgetown. Of the three (Gtown, GW and American), Georgetown absolutely carries the most clout. That said, when the GC recommended it to S, he dismissed it right away. We are not the most observant Jews around, but it just seemed like a bad choice. I don’t know much about GW, except that it has risen in prestige and popularity over the past decade.
I would think that a Jewish student interested in Georgetown might also like UVa or William and Mary for academics, Columbia, UChicago, UPenn for academics with a city location.</p>

<p>As someone already stated, BU, NYU Northeastern are all good city options.</p>

<p>New issue…Union is pushing hard for my son to apply ED. The thought is not rocking my world, but son thinks, “Hell, yeah. Let’s get this over with.” Brilliant.</p>

<p>Can I smack him upside the head or do I just start Happy Hour early?</p>

<p>orangemom - why not both? Smacking him upside the head and starting Happy Hour early that is. But seriously - most recruited athletes are encouraged to apply ED - that seems fairly typical to me. If he LOVES Union and it works for you financially - I say why not? Of course, if he has any hesitations about Union or if you want to be able to compare merit/need-based financial aid packages - then not a good idea. </p>

<p>One additional comment I will make is that sometimes a student is recruited to a particular college for a sport - and that is the whole focus of the search process. Then - something happens - they get injured - they decide they don’t want to play anymore - they are not happy with the coach or the amount of playing time they are getting, etc. - and they drop the sport. Now they are at a college which perhaps was not the best fit for them had the sport not been in the picture. So - do look at it from that perspective as well - would he have Union as his first choice if he was not going to play a sport there - is there enough to do - enough things that he likes about it aside from the sport?</p>

<p>Rockvillemom…took your advice :wink: </p>

<p>My hesitation is due to all your very astute observations. One school he loves, but we are waiting for the ball factor. I’m good w Union. Knowing my son, he will make it work wherever he goes. </p>

<p>I would like to see packages. So the boy will hv to wait. He just such a nudge! </p>

<p>Margarita, anyone?</p>

<p>I completely agree with RVM about making sure that a school is a good fit if the sport doesn’t work out. I’ve seen several kids choose a school based on a sport, only to transfer later. One of my D1’s friends went to a school 7 hours from home that was a terrible social and academic fit because it was the only school that offered her a position in her sport. She was so unhappy that she came home after the first semester, before her sport’s season even started. She is much happier competing on a club team at the state flagship.</p>

<p>Another great option for urban rats is Temple in Philadelphia. Good for solid B students. The area has a bad rep, but I will say we were really impressed with the campus, the safety, what is being developed around the campus and it has the biggest computer loft with about a football fields worth of computers available to the kids to use with all sorts of printers, art computers, music, film, etc. We really liked it. It also has some fine programs for musical theater and art, as well as others. Also, those looking at engineering might want to look at Drexel. It has a wonderful coop program for engineers (at least that is what I have been told). There is a good sized Jewish population in the Philadelphia area, just stay away from the western Main Line! For school it would be fine though I think.</p>

<p>Thank you ALL for the many suggestions, comments, PMs and the like. I sure wish this board had an easy “quote” feature, I’m too scattered to remember everything I want to respond to directly!</p>

<p>Re: U of MD, SHE’s not that interested in the Jewish community LOL, I am. I heard of at least one Jewish girl who got harassed by some Orthodox guys for going out on a Friday night (wish I could remember who told me that), called awful names, etc. I know that’s just anecdotal but still. </p>

<p>I think most of the schools have a Birthright program so that’s certainly NOT a real drawing point. </p>

<p>I’d have to say GW is probably at the top of her list right now, her dad went to Penn so I think she harbors SOME hope of having a shot there, again no money to come her way so unlikely to attend. Will be visiting BU and Northeastern a week from today. Does NOT want to stay in Chicago area, and I’m pretty anti-Michigan and Wisconsin because I don’t think they’re THAT much better than Illinois where we’d have in-state pre-paid tuition to cover 8 semesters. I can barely write that without wanting to cry a little LOL.</p>

<p>Also considering Minnesota, though it’s a Big 10 school and that doesn’t seem her thing, she likes the city location. Their OOS tuition is just a fraction more than our in-state, and they have rolling admissions so I’m guessing that’ll be one of her first applications, just for safety. If she gets in (and lots of money), we’ll go visit, there’s rumblings they want to bring in more Chicago-area kids (which I suspect would be true of any big-city area kid outside MN/WI but I’m making that up so don’t quote me).</p>

<p>Looking more at Pitt too. I sure wish these kids weren’t such darn teenagers, and would just LISTEN to our brilliant suggestions without having to find everything themselves! :-)</p>

<p>Hi, All. I’m back from my business trip and mini vacation (Deborah, were you the one who suggested I visit Powell’s in Portland? I actually made it there! Awesome book store!).</p>

<p>I’m catching up on the recent discussions here and have a question for all of you whose S/D are hoping to play on a sports team at college (even D3). Are you all comfortable with how your S/D will handle time management, given the time requirements of any sports team? My S would LOVE to play on the team for his sport (would have to be D3) at college, but since he wants to study engineering (even BME), I can’t imagine he’d have time. In his sport (tennis), the USTA has an awesome intercollegiate club tennis program (very competitive), so I’ve been steering him towards that. We have an added layer that many of LACs where he might be able to make the team do not have engineering. Still, I’m wondering how you all feel about this. </p>

<p>Because S knows how I feel about this (we have talked about how it is more feasible to works towards a career where you can afford a tennis court at your house than to have a career in tennis!), he is open to the club tennis scene at college. Still, I know he would like to play on an official team. </p>

<p>My only experience is my brother, who attended an Ivy League school, getting in with some assistance from the coach… then his grades slipped and my dad reminded him why he was going to college and that was the end of the team (it’s not like there was an athletic scholarship involved). So, that’s where my bias comes from.</p>

<p>So what are your thoughts?</p>

<p>LINYMOM: D2 was a recruited Div.2-3 athlete in tennis. She visited amazing LACs who wanted her to play for them. In the end, she decided that she would probably not have the time to devote to a pre-med program and a collegiate sport. Unless you have lived the life of a high school athlete, you can’t understand how hard it is for these kids to step away from a sport that has consumed their lives since they were little. Many of the kids who coached with her ended up playing at many Div.1 schools. Their experiences in college opened her eyes to the future. </p>

<p>In fact, the money offers were better from academic scholarships than from any athletic scholarships that were offered to her. Unless you do Div. 1 the money offers, if any, are mediocre. So once she let the “ego” thing go and said she wouldn’t play college ball, she did play club tennis at Michigan and played with amazing varsity players from all over the country. Three of her high school tennis friends play varsity for Michigan–one has already dropped out of the team and another is finding that he cannot keep up with the academics and tennis, and his grades have plummeted (he was a great student in high school.) It tends to restrict your social life because you are away a lot of the weekends. Her friends who play for Iowa all live in a house with other teammates. </p>

<p>Since she was also taking a lot of science classes, many of the labs are scheduled late in the day and on Fridays. This would have created a huge conflict with practice schedules. The club team didn’t get the courts until 10:00 PM–yup, really late practices–but at least it didn’t conflict with classes. She didn’t go to many of the matches because she was in a sorority and that also created conflicts with away matches, but the club team loved having her practice with them and they didn’t care if she didn’t attend matches. For once, she just played for the love of the game.</p>

<p>Your kid will have to decide which he wants more–the sport or engineering. Sometimes, we can’t do it all. BTW, her decision paid off, she is attending medical school in September.</p>

1 Like

<p>S2 wanted to play football at academically selective D-IIIs. Talked to coaches, who said they’d love to have him, but were not going to give him a tip because they felt he’d get in on his very strong academics. (6’4", 250 lb. defensive lineman, captain of the debate team, with terrific scores, full IB diploma and 11 APs.) Halfway through senior year he got cold feet – he had given up other activities in HS in order to spend 25 hrs/week on football, and realized that he wanted to try other stuff in college. He also knew up-front that the academics were more important to him than getting to play.</p>

<p>It probably cost him a couple of admissions because the schools thought he was no longer interested in them (he was, just not in playing football), but now as a college sophomore, he has no regrets about moving on. He plays intramurals in some new sports and has a good time.</p>

<p>My nephew took a full baseball scholarship at a junior college over a couple of D-I acceptances (but he’d be a walk-on at first). His APs and stats put him at the top of the heap at the junior college (as confirmed by his advisor there) – I worry that he will get short shrift on the academics and have trouble when he wants to transfer to the D-I school’s engineering program.</p>

<p>VIRGINIA TECH</p>

<p>I saw this posted and thought I would share because I know there are a few who are considering VT. </p>

<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/virginia-tech/1182317-vt-oversold-dorm-rooms.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/virginia-tech/1182317-vt-oversold-dorm-rooms.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Sujormik: It sounds like you’re putting together a good list for your D. Pitt would be a good safety school for her. They have rolling admission, so you’d get an early response if she applies early. </p>

<p>I hear you on the in-state pre-paid tuition plan. We have the Maryland plan, and I don’t like to think about how much we would have saved if either D had picked an in-state school.</p>

<p>Linymom: I think that you’re on the right track in terms of your son’s sports options. I think that it would be tough to balance a D3 sport with an engineering major. My D1 has has a great experience on a club sports team in college. It allowed her to continue her sport, but also left time to focus on her academics and get involved in other things.</p>

<p>cherryhill - I know - I saw that - oy! Housing and course registration are my two biggest concerns with large universities - VT, JMU and so forth. On the flip side - at least they are asking for volunteers - think about how many schools - and not just large universities have this same issue - and simply do triples for the first semester.</p>

<p>Thank you for all the helpful thoughts about colleges, sports, etc. Several of the PA colleges will remain on D2’s list. Dickinson offers EA which may be a good way to go. D’s gc also suggested looking at Muhlenberg, but it doesn’t offer her sport.</p>

<p>We have also had experience with the challenges of combining division I sports and academics. D1 is a rising junior at an ivy where she competes on a varsity team and has been taking pre-med and other rigorous courses. She has had at least one afternoon lab/week every semester so far, and is often late for practice on those days. Most classes meet M-Th, but some do meet on Fridays which can conflict with travel to competitions (or the competitions themselves). I imagine that in engineering the conflict with Friday classes could be problematic. Also, time constraints can make it difficult to get involved in other ecs and/or have a part-time job though some students do seem to manage this (maybe they require very little sleep?). D looked at division I and III colleges, and chose the former knowing that the sports commitment would be challenging. She loves being part of the team, and so far wouldn’t have it any other way. But only time will tell whether all the juggling is having an impact on her med school prospects (fingers crossed).</p>