Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>A former work colleague now teaches at Goucher. He describes the school as diverse in the best sense–lots of different types of kids, from jocks to purple hair kids, all getting along. It was an original CTCL school, so it is not obscure. RVM’s and momjr’s descriptions are very accurate.</p>

<p>I recall several kids from the HS class of 2010 B thread went there, all of whom had several good choices and parents who conducted extensive research. I believe study abroad is required.</p>

<p>Mom55, your list of “liberal” schools seems on target to me (I do not know much about Wooster, but recall one visitor thinking it nice but more conservative–St. Olaf and Carleton might be good choices, too).</p>

<p>Uskoolfish, there may be fewer differences in your particular program, but, from my experience, the overall student bodies at BU, GW, Syracuse and NYU have much more in common with each other than with Skidmore, Brandeis, Pratt and Goucher. </p>

<p>Best of luck to you both.</p>

<p>Thanks for all of your imput. We visited Goucher two weeks ago and Brandeis last weekend, but visits in the summer don’t allow you to see actual students in order to really assess the social vibe.</p>

<p>The thread that holds all of the schools together is the fact that D would be spending a lot of time with art students. She would prefer an urban setting–thus NYU, BU or GW. (She just completed a 3-week art program at NYU, so she has experienced it first hand.) She would also be OK with a suburban campus that has city access–Brandeis, Pratt, Goucher, Muhlenberg. Skidmore is the exception and one of her top choices. She really likes the town of Saratoga Springs and feels comfortable there. Plus they have the largest art department of any of the liberal arts private colleges. New Paltz and Syracuse are on the list more as safeties, but they also match her academic needs.</p>

<p>Since she is involved in theatre and music in high school, I am not sure about sending her to a more one-dimensional pure art school. The only one that remains on her list is Pratt.</p>

<p>She has a mix of schools that require a portfolio for acceptance (NYU, GW, BU, New Paltz, Syracuse) and those that don’t (Skidmore, Goucher, Muhlenberg and Brandeis.) For those schools we are sending art and music CD’s as supplements, possibly to gain scholarship $.</p>

<p>Oy. Can’t wait for this process to be over! Not only do we have to worry about making the academic cut, but we also have to worry about the totally subjective portfolio review process.</p>

<p>I think we will keep Goucher on the list.</p>

<p>unskoolfish, have you looked at Bard?
Crossover with UVM in our area: Clark, Hobart and William Smith.
Space for “extra information” on Common App: my kids copied and pasted their resumes. Yes, it was redundant but it looked so much better than the list of activities, and they were able to offer explanations of the activities in the resume.</p>

<p>uskoolfish: I guess Pratt could be called suburban in that you have to commute to get to Manhattan, but when I was growing up in Brooklyn I would hardly have called any part of it “suburban”. If you haven’t already, if your daughter is seriously considering it you should visit. BTW I loved it for the semester that I attended 100 years ago… I think that for many students it can be great to attend a school that is more than one dimensional. I planned to be an art major as far back as I could remember but during my first semester of college I started to think that maybe I should look at other things and the only way to do that was to leave.</p>

<p>uskoolfish- when we looked about 6 years at schools , we found Connecticut college had a great art program. Of course, we weren’t looking for it so it wasn’t one that stayed on the list</p>

<p>2 friends’ kids liked Pratt very much and say its name carries great weight in the art world.
A recent grad of Skidmore liked it a lot, although she did not go for art. It has somewhat of a countercultural, intellectual vibe.</p>

<p>uskoolfish - good luck to your D!</p>

<p>My D was looking for theatre programs specifically, but also loves art and music. Her list was very similar. Even though these programs can have enormously specific admissions situations, I can tell you how she did with the schools where they overlap. For the record, her stats were 3.6 (UW, with good but not extreme rigor, regular HS); 31 ACT, 700 SAT2 Verbal (so had some great scores, although a couple of schools are test optional); very good ECs, recs and essays but nothing that would knock one out of the park.</p>

<p>The only overlapping one that had an audition was SUNY New Paltz, where she got in EA academically and accepted to their theatre program later .She got in EA to Goucher, with some nice merit aid. She got in at Bard (no merit offer), and was waitlisted and then accepted quite quickly at Brandeis (also no merit). She did not want to be in Manhattan, and somehow didn’t like Muhlenberg or Skidmore in her web research so they never made the list. I always thought they would have been good BA schools for her, too.</p>

<p>She really liked all of these schools. In the long run, Bard was a bit too remote and while what it did in the arts was excellent, the size of the school did limit the opportunities in her opinion. Goucher seemed lovely, but while she had researched it and met with a rep at a CTCL Fair, she never got to visit (and decided not to in the spring because of better offers). She had a very nice feeling at New Paltz and was very glad to have it as a backup for her auditioned programs, since it does provide quite respectable training, at least in theatre.</p>

<p>In the end, she was accepted to an auditioned BFA in theatre, and the Honors College (a stand-alone Great Books program) at Adelphi, which knocked New Paltz out of contention. She spent several weeks deciding between Adelphi and Brandeis, and in the long run decided that the opportunity to get a BFA meant more to her than reaching for the most highly-ranked school possible. That was utterly a matter of personality and fit, and a snap of the fingers could have sent her the other way.</p>

<p>Another feature that many long-timers here might recall is that she is able to get the BFA, and the intensive special academics, at Adelphi at a very low cost, since Adelphi is giving her its highest merit scholarship. </p>

<p>I expect I’ll have much to say over the next year - presumably positive - about going with merit money at a school where you have very high academic stats, vs. squeaking in (and perhaps squeaking by) at a school where you’re only at the mid-50%. I know she would have done just fine at Brandeis, and ultimately the question was of program, not rankings. My D really had her personal “moment of truth” this May, a very hard but extremely meaningful learning experience.</p>

<p>I feel for you starting the fine arts journey. I too was grateful to my D for deciding the conservatory route was not for her. As a parent I had qualms about that, although I would have been supportive nonetheless. I’m just glad I didn’t have to face that issue in the long run. Being in a BFA within a university is just perfect for her - lots of conservatory-like classes, plus an intense study abroad at least one semester, but also the opportunity to “be in college,” which was very important to her.</p>

<p>Hi again!</p>

<p>Levrim: I looked into Bard, but I believe the location is too remote. Especially since she enjoyed NYU so much this summer.</p>

<p>Spectrum2: I laughed to myself when I listed Pratt as “suburban.” I grew up in Brooklyn. too (Ocean Parkway in Kensington)! Although the area around Pratt is much improved, in the end, through my D’s eyes, Brooklyn is a suburb to Manhattan. And with its self-contained campus, Pratt is like a school whose campus is outside of a major city. Apologies to all the hipsters of Williamsburg! The good thing about Pratt though is that it does offer a BFA in art education which is D’s ultimate goal. So her art classes will be mixed up with some ed classes and othe liberal art requirements. But I still have concerns with it being one-dimensional.</p>

<p>Fourkidsmom: Connecticut College hasn’t been on our radar. I will look into it. : )</p>

<p>Emmybet: Thank you for your long post. There are many similarities between schools for art kids and those for theatre/music. I know first hand because older D is in her last year at NYU getting a BM degree in Vocal Performance with a specialization in Musical Theatre. She is at Steinhardt which houses the art department my younger D is applying to. That is why I wanted her to go to the summer art program there. I wanted her to have her own experience at NYU and to form her own conclusions. (It is her top choice, but a reach.)</p>

<p>My older D applied and was accepted to Brandeis (with $15K in merit aid which they are no longer giving out), Barnard, Muhlenberg, GW, American and Binghamton. She got good merit aid from Muhlenberg, American and GW. She got $11K from NYU. So a lot of the same schools.</p>

<p>Younger D will be applying for art merit aid at GW, Goucher, BU and Syracuse, music merit aid at Skidmore, and art/theatre/music merit aid at Muhlenberg. However, I am not sure how it will play out. The climate for merit aid has shifted, so I am not holding my breath. And if she decides to ED NYU, there is zero chance of merit. (But if she applies RD, I don’t think she will get more than $5K if she gets anything at all.)</p>

<p>I can see that a decision between Brandeis and Adelphi could be hard given the differences in the degrees offered as well as the money.</p>

<p>I think Brandeis would be a real reach for D, but who knows? Her GPA would be higher if she didn’t struggle with trig and chem in sophomore year. She has a 610 in SAT math and 23 in math on the ACT. But she has a 720 in reading on the SAT and a 35 in English on the ACT. Also a 650 on Bio SAT as a freshman, 6 college credits for Anatomy and Physiology and a 27 in science ACT. So she is a little lopsided and inconsistent. I do think that Brandeis will like her art/ theatre and music background. Plus lots of leadership/ community service. It is so hard to second guess schools, especially when they claim to be “holistic.”</p>

<p>I live on Long Island, about 25 minutes from Adelphi. If you or your D ever have any Long Island questions, feel free to contact me.</p>

<p>Thanks again for everyone’s imput.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Have you considered Temple?
[Temple</a> University Undergraduate Bulletin - Tyler/Art Education](<a href=“http://www.temple.edu/bulletin/academic_programs/schools_colleges/tyler/programs/art_ed/tyler_art_ed.shtm]Temple”>http://www.temple.edu/bulletin/academic_programs/schools_colleges/tyler/programs/art_ed/tyler_art_ed.shtm)</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.temple.edu/bulletin/academic_programs/schools_colleges/tyler/programs/bfa/tyler_bfa.shtm#bfa_teach[/url]”>http://www.temple.edu/bulletin/academic_programs/schools_colleges/tyler/programs/bfa/tyler_bfa.shtm#bfa_teach&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Either a BS or a BFA in Art Education from a well-respected art program, in a full-scale university with other options. Also an urban setting. And I believe they offer merit scholarships.</p>

<p>uskoolfish, have you or your D considered U of Delaware? The son of a friend entered their program in '07 so not sure of more up-to-date status, but he found it pretty rigorous in a classic college setting.</p>

<p>This may not work for unskoolfish as it might not be urban enough, but there seems to be crossover for these kids interested in the arts between the schools mentioned and Ithaca College.</p>

<p>I’m realizing we’re in a very different ballgame here if a kid thinks Brooklyn is “too suburban.” Hm. Lots of theatre kids look at Pace, Marymount Manhattan, Eugene Lang, etc. to have the highest chances of being in Manhattan proper. I don’t know much about them for studio art, though. </p>

<p>What about DePaul, Roosevelt, Columbia College Chicago? Those are incredibly urban campuses, right in the heart of the city (especially the last two). Or the School of the Art Institute of Chicago? Really interesting things happening there.</p>

<p>Delaware is too big a campus, although we know a lot of kids going there for all different majors. It is one of those schools that she just wasn’t into.</p>

<p>Ithaca College is in Ithaca. It works for a lot of people and we know kids going there, but D wouldn’t consider it after visiting Cornell with older D.</p>

<p>I’m going to look into Temple. We know a theatre kid there who loves it. Not thrilled with the location, but I hear it is on an upswing.</p>

<p>Chicago is too far. I have tried to stick with a 5 hour driving distance from NYC–that’s my personal requirement.</p>

<p>D doesn’t exactly feel that Pratt is suburban…only in the context of its proximity to the city. Actually, D likes the suburbs as long as a vibrant city is nearby. The problem is the only cities that fit that bill are NY, Boston and DC.</p>

<p>Hopefully she will have options even though some of the schools she is applying to are reaches.</p>

<p>uskoolfish, has your D visited Pratt, taken the subway to midtown? It’s about the same distance as it is from Columbia to midtown! And much closer to the social scene (cough…bar scene) in Williamsburg, Soho, Nolita, the Village. You’re from LI so you no doubt know all this but if the school is otherwise a good fit…</p>

<p>We are not ruling out Pratt at all. We did visit and came away loving it a little less than we had hoped for. I lived in Brooklyn up until my mid-thirties when I made the move to Long Island, so I was rooting for the school and neighborhood. I was hoping for more restaurants (and yes, bars) walking distance from the school. Of course Wiliamsburg is thriving, but the area around Pratt isn’t as vibrant as I had hoped.</p>

<p>We have not done the subway connection into the city. That is a whole other issue because from what I have been told the subway line isn’t the best especially if kids are coming and going late at night. I will save that until it is a definite possibility. Older D at NYU has spent plenty of money late at night on cabs, so that is an option–though an expensive one–if necessary.</p>

<p>I do love Brooklyn and many of my older D’s friends are moving there. But it is still not like living in the middle of Manhattan. The issue is $ in the end. The kicker is that Pratt isn’t that much less than NYU though.</p>

<p>I’m from the north and Clark is a good school, although I’ve never thought of it being a school that a lot of Jews go to. How about BU, Brandeis or Northeastern University?</p>

<p>Actually - Clark University has about 400 Jewish students - making it well over 10% Jewish - closer to 15%. Looks like they have a new Hillel website - not much content on there yet - just a welcome event at the end of August:</p>

<p>[Clark</a> University Hillel](<a href=“http://www.clarkhillel.com/]Clark”>http://www.clarkhillel.com/)</p>

<p>They also offer Jewish Studies:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.clarku.edu/departments/jewishstudies/[/url]”>http://www.clarku.edu/departments/jewishstudies/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>and the Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.clarku.edu/departments/holocaust/[/url]”>http://www.clarku.edu/departments/holocaust/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>This Fast Facts section from their website lists the Jewish population at 13%:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.clarku.edu/fastfacts.cfm[/url]”>http://www.clarku.edu/fastfacts.cfm&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>“I was hoping for more restaurants (and yes, bars) walking distance from the school. Of course Wiliamsburg is thriving, but the area around Pratt isn’t as vibrant as I had hoped.”</p>

<p>Theres some serious residential gentrication going on in many of the blocks right adjacent to Pratt - I dont know about the bars and eateries.</p>

<p>a few blocks east - just across the BQE - a major residential transformation is well underway, that is NOT being driven by art students, hipsters, or yuppies. That whole corner of Bed Stuy between flushing avenue and myrtle is becoming hasidic, as they move down from South Williamsburg. Sometimes they live cheek by jowl (so to speak) with artsy types coming east from the Pratt area. </p>

<p>ive walked the area (during the day) and find it fascinating.</p>

<p>I have to laugh a little. I guess I’ve lived in the Midwest too long. Moved “away” from Brooklyn to LI (and I know not too far east on LI, since it’s close to Garden City)? Here I am thinking that from Adelphi one could easily explore Brooklyn, Queens, etc. because in my perspective they’re practically adjacent. We’re not worried about things being literally in the same neighborhood (like a few blocks) from her school (although we of course do want her to be safe with transportation).</p>

<p>I grew up in Boston and know what it’s like to be in a concentrated part of the country. But around here, “close” is within a 2-hour drive, and “far” is driving all day!</p>

<p>I’m sure D will find the 40-minute train to Manhattan a little tiresome at times, but I don’t think she’ll ever feel she’s not close to the city or that she doesn’t have access to tons of entertainment, culture, etc.</p>

<p>Temple’s art program is very good. The area around it is still troublesome (although the campus is secure) and the subway from Temple to center city Philly would concern me much more than the subway from Pratt to Manhattan. The wealth of trendy clubs and Williamsburg, DUMBO and the Bwery is just astounding to those of us who saw them a decade ago. The Times recently reported that Bed-Stuy is now attracting a lot of gentrifiers who want a bargain relative to Williamsburg. </p>

<p>In art, as in many cases where your child (at least for now) has a very strong interest, the overall prestige of the school is not the equivalent of the quality of a particular program.</p>