<p>uskoolfish - good luck to your D!</p>
<p>My D was looking for theatre programs specifically, but also loves art and music. Her list was very similar. Even though these programs can have enormously specific admissions situations, I can tell you how she did with the schools where they overlap. For the record, her stats were 3.6 (UW, with good but not extreme rigor, regular HS); 31 ACT, 700 SAT2 Verbal (so had some great scores, although a couple of schools are test optional); very good ECs, recs and essays but nothing that would knock one out of the park.</p>
<p>The only overlapping one that had an audition was SUNY New Paltz, where she got in EA academically and accepted to their theatre program later .She got in EA to Goucher, with some nice merit aid. She got in at Bard (no merit offer), and was waitlisted and then accepted quite quickly at Brandeis (also no merit). She did not want to be in Manhattan, and somehow didn’t like Muhlenberg or Skidmore in her web research so they never made the list. I always thought they would have been good BA schools for her, too.</p>
<p>She really liked all of these schools. In the long run, Bard was a bit too remote and while what it did in the arts was excellent, the size of the school did limit the opportunities in her opinion. Goucher seemed lovely, but while she had researched it and met with a rep at a CTCL Fair, she never got to visit (and decided not to in the spring because of better offers). She had a very nice feeling at New Paltz and was very glad to have it as a backup for her auditioned programs, since it does provide quite respectable training, at least in theatre.</p>
<p>In the end, she was accepted to an auditioned BFA in theatre, and the Honors College (a stand-alone Great Books program) at Adelphi, which knocked New Paltz out of contention. She spent several weeks deciding between Adelphi and Brandeis, and in the long run decided that the opportunity to get a BFA meant more to her than reaching for the most highly-ranked school possible. That was utterly a matter of personality and fit, and a snap of the fingers could have sent her the other way.</p>
<p>Another feature that many long-timers here might recall is that she is able to get the BFA, and the intensive special academics, at Adelphi at a very low cost, since Adelphi is giving her its highest merit scholarship. </p>
<p>I expect I’ll have much to say over the next year - presumably positive - about going with merit money at a school where you have very high academic stats, vs. squeaking in (and perhaps squeaking by) at a school where you’re only at the mid-50%. I know she would have done just fine at Brandeis, and ultimately the question was of program, not rankings. My D really had her personal “moment of truth” this May, a very hard but extremely meaningful learning experience.</p>
<p>I feel for you starting the fine arts journey. I too was grateful to my D for deciding the conservatory route was not for her. As a parent I had qualms about that, although I would have been supportive nonetheless. I’m just glad I didn’t have to face that issue in the long run. Being in a BFA within a university is just perfect for her - lots of conservatory-like classes, plus an intense study abroad at least one semester, but also the opportunity to “be in college,” which was very important to her.</p>